News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @02:35PM (#1844243)
And your post is willfully ignorant of the fact that most of your taxes don't pay for the public goods you've listed. Roads, sewers, police and clean water are a ridiculously tiny fraction of what you pay in taxes. If you exclude waste in the military (and the other small ticket items you mention), it is even smaller.

Most of your taxes are simply taken and given to people less productive than yourself.

Re:John Carmack on government by jbooth on Thursday October 28, 2010 @03:33PM (#1844538)
Fine, then. If you want to be all against those programs, then explicitly say "What I want is for social security and medicare to be abolished". SS and Medicare run entirely separate from the rest of the federal gov't, raised on their own taxes, run by their own agencies -- they're entirely separate. You're not "anti government" and don't have a point about "government", you have a point about federally mandated social insurance programs that are incredibly popular with everyone else.

A bunch of whining about "government" just betrays either ignorance or willful omission by people who talk about "smaller government" in between assuring seniors that their medicare is safe.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @03:58PM (#1844661)
I was only pointing out a logical flaw in paulsmith's argument. I wasn't taking a position one way or the other.

But I'll be explicit in my position since you want to imply I'm being deceptive about it: the government should not pay for private goods.

I'm not going to debate the matter here, however, beyond pointing out that in a population of 2 wolves and 1 sheep, lamb chops are an incredibly popular dinner choice.

Re:John Carmack on government by jbooth on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:02PM (#1844677)
"the government should not pay for private goods" -- this is the kind of evasive, hand-wavey crap that I'm talking about. Sorry about the tone, I don't mean to be insulting and think you're an alright guy from our interactions, but it is hand wavey crap. I constantly see conservatives talking about "smaller government and lower taxes" and I never hear one idea from them about what they'd cut, let alone an acknowledgement of the fact that we had a budget surplus in 2000 and very much not in 2008.

What does that sentence mean? Who defines "private good"? Are interstate highways a public good? Are positive externalities from a social safety net a public good?

Re:John Carmack on government by lotharbot on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:24PM (#1844792)
> "this is the kind of evasive, hand-wavey crap that I'm talking about."

It's evasive and hand-wavey because you don't know what an economics term means and didn't take 30 seconds to look it up on google or wikipedia? I expect better from everyone on HN.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_goods

Something is a private good if:

- it can be distributed individually (that is, you can allow only those who've paid for it or registered for it to use it)

- its use/consumption by one party precludes its use by another party

Roadways can probably be categorized as a "club good" -- they can be used by multiple people, but it's possible to make them available only to "paying customers". Toll roads are a club good for those who pay the toll, while other roads are a club good for all registered/licensed motorists.

To be a truly "public good" it needs to be impossible to exclude non-payers; things like clean air or military protection are public goods.

Externalities are not goods; they are costs or benefits associated with goods but incurred by outside parties.

Re:John Carmack on government by jbooth on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:39PM (#1844853)
Of course I know what the term means. The point is that the term is mushy enough to be meaningless in all but the most trivial of applications. Nobody thinks the government should be competing with Sam's club in the retail breakfast cereal market. If something's being debated, it's almost by definition in the gray area.

"I don't think the government should produce private goods" means effectively nothing.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:54PM (#1844926)
Dude, just apply the definition. No honest person is debating that SS/medicare are private goods, they are only debating whether the government should pay for them anyway. Just to avoid being accused of handwaving, I'll write out the obvious reasoning explicitly.

Medicare: Rivalrous (the same dollar can't reimburse the doctor for your benefits and mine) and excludible (if you don't pay, they don't reimburse the doctor). Private good.

SS: Rivalrous (you and I can't both spend an SS check) and excludible (if you don't pay in while young, they don't send you a check when you are old). Private good.

Should I do the same thing for cheese fries or can you figure out for yourself that cheese fries are also a private good?

Re:John Carmack on government by hugh3 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @06:41PM (#1845256)
I agree with you, but I'm gonna argue the other side right now since I see an objection to that particular line of argument.

Suppose I now say that welfare is a public good since without it we'd have poor folks either rioting or dying in the streets. I benefit from that and so do you.

Another line-blurring example: food in prison is a private good in that only one prisoner can eat it; however I don't have a problem with the government paying for that.

Re:John Carmack on government by lotharbot on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:04PM (#1845336)
One could argue that welfare benefits the public, but that is not the same as saying welfare checks are public goods. It's a technical term that doesn't say anything about the external benefits to the public.

Welfare checks are private goods, because if the funds go into one person's check the same funds can't also go into another person's check (rivalrous) and the checks can be sent to some people but not others (excludable).

Food and clothing for prisoners or for military personnel are also private goods, though they're better categorized as components of the public goods of "functional criminal justice system" and "military protection".

Re:John Carmack on government by hugh3 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @08:33PM (#1845572)
So we appear to be in blurry-definitionland. Meals for prisoners are private goods which are part of the public good "functional criminal justice system". Welfare checks for unemployed bums are private goods which are part of the public good "no dead hobos on lawns".
Re:John Carmack on government by lotharbot on Thursday October 28, 2010 @10:33PM (#1845821)
"no dead hobos on lawns" is not a good, it's a service. Various goods might contribute to that service, such as "homeless shelters" and "welfare checks".

I suppose "functional criminal justice system" is actually a service, as well, while "prison" is a good.

Re:John Carmack on government by steamer25 on Monday November 01, 2010 @12:18PM (#1856994)
I would absolutely be in favor of prisoners (sentenced via due process) earning their own board. E.g., washing government vehicles, cleaning highways, hauling landscaping materials for erosion control projects at state parks, etc. etc.
Re:John Carmack on government by jbooth on Thursday October 28, 2010 @11:26PM (#1845987)
"Apply the definition"? It's a qualitative term in a qualitative field. Everything in economics is about quantifying your qualitative assumptions of things. Which is probably the best way to study the matter.

But don't miss the forest for the trees here. Your problem is with entitlements, not some grander definition of public/private goods. I mean, if I could convince you SS was a public good, it wouldn't change your opinion, right?

Re:John Carmack on government by jobeirne on Friday October 29, 2010 @02:47PM (#1848457)
> I mean, if I could convince you SS was a public good, it wouldn't change your opinion, right?

Yeah, it would, though I strongly doubt you can do that given the definition of ``public good.''

Re:John Carmack on government by smokeyj on Thursday October 28, 2010 @06:49PM (#1845286)
"- its use/consumption by one party precludes its use by another party"

I'm glad you don't view intellectual property as legitimate property.

Re:John Carmack on government by lotharbot on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:07PM (#1845347)
I don't view intellectual property as private goods; it doesn't meet the definition. I said nothing about its legitimacy as property, nor do I intend to, as that's not the topic at hand.

Please do not drag the discussion off topic by twisting the definition given into something it's not.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:44PM (#1844880)
Lotharbot pointed you to wikipedia which explains it pretty well.

Interstate highways are a public good, at least for as long as technology is not advanced enough to make metering them/excluding freeloaders feasible.

As for what I'd cut, social security, medicare and welfare are at the top of my list. Quite a few conservatives (the limited government kind, not the "Dem + Christian nationalism" kind) have explicitly stated this, for example Paul Ryan. See our conversation from a month ago, the last time I pointed this fact out to you: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1745714 (I believe Ron Paul also pushes cutting SS/medicare.)

Re:John Carmack on government by jfager on Thursday October 28, 2010 @06:51PM (#1845296)
Tollbooths?

And what about the military? Military protection is commonly cited as a public good, but sustaining the military requires massive government expenditures on private goods. How does that square with the idea that the government shouldn't pay for private goods?

I think you're being overly harsh on the idea that the public/private goods distinction isn't always black-and-white. There are many obvious gray areas.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:29PM (#1845414)
When tollbooths are feasible, roads are indeed a private good. You are indeed correct that many of the intermediate goods in providing a public good are private goods when they are sold.

I'm not sure what this has to do with anything, unless you are discussing something silly like the government buying tanks and giving them to private individuals. There are gray areas, but I think the biggies in the federal budget are pretty clear.

Re:John Carmack on government by jfager on Thursday October 28, 2010 @08:13PM (#1845528)
The point is, where do you draw the line? If you're comfortable with government spending money on private goods that are intermediate goods for military protection, then why not with government spending money on social programs that can be seen as intermediate goods for other kinds of public goods?
Re:John Carmack on government by steamer25 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @03:52PM (#1844627)
What I want is for social security and medicare to be abolished.
Re:John Carmack on government by cjbprime on Friday October 29, 2010 @07:00AM (#1846844)
Excellent post, reminds me of http://log.ometer.com/2009-09.html .
Re:John Carmack on government by tensor on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:51PM (#1844917)
Most of your taxes are simply taken and given to people less productive than yourself.

Citations please.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:55PM (#1844929)
Already provided if you scrolled down. Here it is again:

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html

Re:John Carmack on government by tensor on Thursday October 28, 2010 @05:25PM (#1845038)
None of those except perhaps welfare implies that the money is going to people less productive than yourself. Also, I'm sure many people on welfare would love to have a good job and be productive.
Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @05:49PM (#1845102)
People who have retired from productive labor are, by definition, not productive.

As for people on welfare wanting to work, that's unclear. Most (about 80%) poor people don't want to work [1] and I expect the ones who do work are less likely to be on welfare (though I don't have stats granular enough to prove this). Do you have a better estimate?

[1] http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2008.pdf

Re:John Carmack on government by macrael on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:10PM (#1845360)
Sorry, did you get that "80% of poor people don't want to work" figure by dividing the number of working poor by the total number of poor people from that report you linked to?[1] I didn't see any information in that study pertaining to motivation or desire. Just because 75% of people below the poverty line were not employed for half the year does not mean that they did not want to be.

[1] http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2008.pdf

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @07:23PM (#1845393)
Just because 75% of people below the poverty line were not employed for half the year...

Go read the first 3 sentences of the report. That includes clauses inside parenthesis.

Re:John Carmack on government by macrael on Thursday October 28, 2010 @08:26PM (#1845557)
Quite right you are. I still take some issue with the idea that 75% of the poor don't want to work. The report is not entirely clear on what it means to be "looking for work", and it's hard to know what different motivations are driving that 10% of the american population. But, absent data, I will concede the point.
Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @09:38PM (#1845706)
"Persons are classified as unemployed if they do not have a job, have actively looked for work in the prior 4 weeks, and are currently available for work."

More details: http://www.bls.gov/cps/cps_htgm.htm

By the way, didn't mean to sound hostile in my last post. I think I came across a little stronger than I meant.

Re:John Carmack on government by larrywright on Thursday October 28, 2010 @11:51PM (#1846043)
Also, I'm sure many people on welfare would love to have a good job and be productive.

It probably depends on how you define "many", but I don't think history sides with you on this one. Welfare programs in the US have tended to produce more people on welfare, rather than getting them off.

Re:John Carmack on government by borism on Thursday October 28, 2010 @03:21PM (#1844484)
he didn't talk only about taxes HE paid. There were 10+ generations that paid taxes to the United States of America for the last 200+ years to become what it is now.

even if I agreed with your assumption (which I don't), I would certainly not be able to agree that US taxpayers subsidized "less productive" for past 200+ years and US still became what it is now.

Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @03:52PM (#1844624)
even if I agreed with your assumption (which I don't)

The facts are easy to check:

http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year2008_US.html

Of the top 5 biggest expenditures in the US as of 2008 (the last year for which full data is available), only the #4 expenditure (the military) was a public good. The #1,2,3 and 5 items together account for 58% of government spending in the US.

The basics mentioned by the original poster are actually pretty cheap. Water and sewers are about 2% of government spending. Police, fire, prison and courts were only 6%. Roads are another 5%. The military (the biggest public good expense) is only 14%.

Re:John Carmack on government by jokermatt999 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:22PM (#1844776)
I'd argue that education is a public good. Even if you don't have kids, it seems like it would be in your interest to ensure that the people who will be running things in the future are informed and competent.
Re:John Carmack on government by yummyfajitas on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:46PM (#1844893)
By this logic, any investment is a public good.

Of course, education isn't a public good. It's rivalrous (you and I can't simultaneously enjoy the same seat in a classroom) and excludible (if you don't pay, they don't let you in). That makes it a private good.

Re:John Carmack on government by jokermatt999 on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:59PM (#1844940)
You're correct on "not a public good", sorry. Complete economics brainfart; I was thinking public good = for the common good. I'm not sure who downvoted you or why, but I modded you back to +1.

I do still think that education should be a function of the government, however.

Edit to expand on my position: I had confused the terms public good and common good. I believe that a solid, (to some extent, but not as far as we are now) standardized education system is in the best interest of our nation. I don't think this could be provided privately.

Re:John Carmack on government by enki on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:39PM (#1844849)
please look up the terms 'public good' and 'private good'
Re:John Carmack on government by Symmetry on Thursday October 28, 2010 @04:00PM (#1844672)
You seem to be missing a word on that last sentence, so my apologies if I'm misreading you. John Carmack talked about what he saw as the problem getting worse, and I think he would say that most of what we spent money on 200 years ago was money well spent. In fact, I would be very surprised if there were many things that the government did 200 years ago which he would be against the government continuing to do.
Re:John Carmack on government by borism on Thursday October 28, 2010 @06:47PM (#1845278)
I would be very surprised if people 200, 150, 100, 50 years ago didn't think that things are getting worse and worse with government spending. And yet somehow America grew to become the World Power, long-lasting businesses were created, government-funded research led to many advances etc. And very often all that happened while tax rates were much MUCH higher and government was very much involved. So I call out BS.