Re:People are “consistently inconsistent” in reasoning about...
by richk449 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:22AM
(#18441600)
> A simpler example that I recently went through was that I stopped drinking alcohol. I never had a problem with alcohol and would have beer or wine here and there. But, the evidence keeps mounting that it's literally just putting poison in your body with little benefits. I felt it was inconsistent for me to workout everyday, eat healthy, and then drink alcohol. So I stopped rationalizing and quit.
Isn't this an example of you being the sole reasonable one? Exactly the thing the parent post was suggesting we avoid writing about?
Re:People are “consistently inconsistent” in reasoning about...
by matwood on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:31AM
(#18441670)
I'm not trying to change anyone else's opinion on alcohol. I'm just trying to make my own internal opinions consistent.
I viewed the parents post as to avoid "I'm the only smart one in the group, and everyone else is wrong." Which I agree is a good attitude to avoid. In a group setting, it is much too easy to let our ego get in the way of evidence.
Re:People are “consistently inconsistent” in reasoning about...
by Skrillex on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @10:57AM
(#18441901)
The parent was not being rational, and noted that they were doing the same thing as other people. They later changed their behavior due to exposure to outside information. It seems explicit to me that the parent admits to being wrong here.
Agreed. This is something I think about a lot. I like consistency and am always trying to reconcile my personal beliefs with each other. It can be quite hard because it leads to questioning other beliefs that may be deeply held. The classic example is logic/reasoning and religion.
A simpler example that I recently went through was that I stopped drinking alcohol. I never had a problem with alcohol and would have beer or wine here and there. But, the evidence keeps mounting that it's literally just putting poison in your body with little benefits. I felt it was inconsistent for me to workout everyday, eat healthy, and then drink alcohol. So I stopped rationalizing and quit.