News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:35AM (#18439549)
Pilots SHOULD be trained to deal with situations like this - getting trained in simulators replicating the conditions that caused previous accidents.

But, that's theoretical. I'm hearing pilots get massively underpaid for the responsibility they have, unless they gain an x amount of flight hours and years of experience so they can do big intercontinental flights (= more flight hours, = more income). It's up to the industry to fix this problem, also to fix their own shortage of pilots. Pay pilots a decent wage when they're starting out on their career. Give them the opportunities to gain the flight hours.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:51AM (#18440064)
Training is extensive and regular re-certification is not optional. However, modern airliners are complex machines with many weird failure modes that rarely occur. Many of these scenarios are covered only occasionally during certifications since there is no chance to cover them all. Many of these scenarios never occur during a pilot's career but when they do they only may have seconds to take action. Instructors have to choose what to focus on. I'd say this is an example of something that slipped through as something worthy of focusing on.

IMHO the long term solution to improving safety is to make the pilots increasingly redundant. With the current generation of technology this is not yet feasible since they are depending on a wide range of technologies dating back decades. Also a lot of the planes flying are decades old designs. This makes them hard to automate and human-computer interaction has not evolved to the point where a computer can take over these tasks and deal with all the critical human interactions that are involved with operating a plane. In principle the problem is solvable, however. It's mostly just a matter of enough sensors and computation redundancy and improving communication technology to get humans out of the loop.

Mostly pilots these days take executive decisions that boil down to religiously following checklists for basically every scenario imaginable and programming the auto pilot to act accordingly. The auto pilot is activated right after take off and typically disabled on final moments before touch down; or in some cases after landing. Or as in this case, in an emergency.

That's not to marginalize their role. Flying an airliner is a two man operation and they tend to be extremely busy dealing with flying complex procedures, routing around weather, ad hoc queues from controllers, cross checking each other, etc. Most of that stuff requires pilots to have good situational awareness. Most of that awareness is created through reading their instruments, communicating on their radio, and looking outside (when weather permits).

All of that could be automated but it would require a complete rethink of how this business works. For example modern planes are basically equipped with multiple redundant computers and fly by wire control (i.e. a computer controls everything). Yet, critical information is passed to these computers via a non digital communications channel involving people trying to exchange crucial bits of information over a badly congested, low quality radio channel with limited range. This is a ridiculously convoluted, error prone, and hopelessly inefficient way of communicating. The only reason it exists is because agreeing and standardizing on something sensible is going to take decades and has taken decades already.

Most of the chatter on the radio is people cross verifying completely routine information. Worse, people on both sides tend to be very overloaded with information and yet lack the mechanisms to share information other than verbally. Controllers can be juggling communication with dozens of planes and pilots are bogged down in a barrage of instructions, complex procedures, and checklists. A lot of the training focuses on teaching both to stay on top of this (this is very hard). A lot of accidents result from their failure to do so. Emergencies are stressful and stress makes all this even harder.

So, a completely computer based system would do away with most of that to reduce task overload for pilots and controllers and ultimately reduce both of them to the role of remote managers that intervene by exception and very rarely. Ultimately such a system would run itself. Military drones are slightly ahead of the curve here.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by CPLX on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @06:53AM (#18440299)
> Yet, critical information is passed to these computers via a non digital communications channel involving people trying to exchange crucial bits of information over a badly congested, low quality radio channel with limited range.

This is really arguable.

People always go on about how voice radio communication on a shared channel is from the Stone Age, but what’s better, and why, and can you prove it?

I feel like people drastically underestimate the degree to which the current radio system succeeds in providing situational awareness. We are wired to processs and respond to input from human voices extremely quickly and intuitively with lots of nuance, and our visual and tactile systems are pretty well saturated with information while flying.

What’s your superior suggestion? Saying “computers” or “automation” is going to have to address the fact that those things have some issues as well.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @08:46AM (#18440855)
I watch quite a lot of youtube pilot footage; just a strange hobby of mine. Watch any youtube pilot doing IFR flights and note how they struggle to stay on top of the radios (depending on their currency and experience). Most pilots know from hard experience that this is a skill that goes within weeks/months if they stop practicing. They know they will start mangling their radio work and make other mistakes. That's because it is freaking hard. It's by far the hardest part of flying a plane. Actually flying them is easy. You'll be flying solo in no time at all. From there to instrument rating, takes years typically. Being an instrument rated pilot means a life of practice and training.

Much of the pilot training for an instrument rating is about staying on top of the radios, dealing with the enormous task load, and planning ahead as to what is going to be required next. As soon as you loose the plot there, you are in trouble: you lose situational awareness, controllers get pissed, things get very stressful, mistakes get made, etc. Many private pilots chicken out from ever getting their instrument rating since it is so enormously challenging and intimidating and since maintaining it is such a big commitment as well.

Most of this is for the perfectly valid reason that this extremely limited and unreliable medium of shouting out letters as words over congested and distorted radio channels is literally the only way to communicate with controllers.

The fix is obvious: send messages over authenticated digital channels with some integrity/sanity checks using some well defined protocol. Start requiring this for all commercial aviation and ban planes from critical air space that are not able to communicate that way. Important messages should require acknowledgement from pilots. There should be zero doubt for pilots about the current status of controller provided altimeter settings, weather report, most recent instructions, etc. Likewise controllers should be able to pick up planes the second their radios and transponders are turned on. This should not be optional. There should be no need for transponder codes. There should be zero doubt about which plane is where for the controller,the entire history of that plane, it's current journey, it's pilot,all previous communications, etc. None of that should need to be communicated or verified by voice, ever.

Voice channels should be reserved for emergencies. Controllers should be able to talk to any plane without delay. These channels should have stuff like caller id and other fancy stuff any decent mobile phone has been capable off for decades. There should be no need to ever yell out call signs and hope that the other side got it jotted down correctly. Etc.

This is not particularly hard to design technically and hasn't been for a long time. Sure you'd want a sane design and lots of built in checks and balances and back up systems, etc.

But agreeing that it needs to be designed, and then agreeing on a particular design is what the problem is here. If you doubt there is a problem, consider that essentially every major plane crash gets blamed on "pilot error" and translate that as "they accidentally crashed the plane because they got confused about what to do under the enormous task-load". When shit goes wrong, having a lot of confusion about who said what, who did what, what was the pilot, plane doing, etc. seems standard. There's no need for that, at all. E.g. Most of the stuff on a black box should be stored remotely long before the plane hits the ground.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by CPLX on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:04AM (#18440975)
I’m a licensed pilot. I remain skeptical of your argument.

There’s no question that staying on top of a complex flight has a heavy mental load. But I’m not convinced radio is the problem.

The information has to be conveyed somehow. Having humans at every step is a clear sanity check.

Either you cut humans out of the job of decision making and have computers make decisions, which introduces all sorts of new issues, or you have to give humans information and context.

And as long as humans are in charge, humans talking to other humans is underrated as a means of getting a lot of information across quickly and effectively.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:52AM (#18442450)
I'd argue the current style of communication is effective (by design) but neither quick nor easy out of necessity.

Basically, aviation has a long history of increasing safety by taking tedious complicated tasks away from humans (e.g. dedicated navigators, radio operators, and engineers used to be a thing). This is just the next obvious thing to tackle. I'd also argue pilot stress and task load is the biggest killer in the aviation industry and the single biggest root cause of every crash ever.

Also, I'd argue this is an extra tool. Of course talking to controllers and other pilots in the area should always be an option. Especially, at uncontrolled fields. Wouldn't it be nice if you can skip the formalities of telling over and over again who you are, where you are, etc. because the other side already knows this?

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by Shivatron on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:30AM (#18442210)
As an instrument-rated pilot, I reject your brazen assertion that radio work is "by far the hardest part of flying a plane." Are you speaking from personal experience, or do you have some data to back up this claim?

From an instrument proficiency point of view, I'm much more worried about efficiently understanding the information on the approach plate, maintaining situational awareness with respect to the approach path, adhering to minimums, and so on. Missed something that a controller said? "Say again." There's a reason it's aviate, navigate, and communicate--in that order.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by jillesvangurp on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:40PM (#18445178)
I can bounce that right back. Do you have solid data proving beyond reasonable doubt that task saturation is not a major factor in airline crashes (considering pilot error is cited frequently as a root cause)? And would you reject tools that reduce task load because of that?

You bring up a fine point: aviate, navigate, and communicate - in that order. Very sensible when everything is manual and you are task saturated to drop tasks in that priority; which is what this is about. If you automate communication and remove most of the task load related to that and navigation, it frees you up to let the auto pilot do the aviation bit.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by ams6110 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @11:27PM (#18447478)
But as soon as any or all of that fails, you have to fall back to voice communication. And if the pilots aren't used to doing that, and well practiced in the standard phraseology, it will be very prone to error or misunderstanding.
Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by nradov on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @12:58PM (#18443086)
I'm skeptical whether automation of handling failures will be feasible. For example, Chesley "Sully" Sullenberger of US Airways Flight 1549 "Miracle on the Hudson" fame intentionally skipped steps on the checklist for handling engine failure because he didn't have time to go through everything, and the checklist itself didn't quite fit the actual situation which obtained at the time. In the end that proved to be the correct decision.
Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by ainiriand on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @03:45AM (#18439588)
Maybe in the US, here in EU even the newest Ryanair pilot makes 100k.

https://careers.ryanair.com/pilots/pilotpayincreases/

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by alistairSH on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @09:03AM (#18440968)
In the US, new commercial pilots (with ATP license) earn somewhere in the $20k-$40k range.[1] And many take on massive debt for the privilege - college degree and flight training together can cost upwards of $200k.[2]

1 - http://fortune.com/2014/03/03/why-airlines-are-running-out-o... 2 - https://daytonabeach.erau.edu/admissions/estimated-costs/

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by colde on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:21AM (#18439715)
Yeah, thats not true. The chart you link to says new first officers based in Dublin make 78.400 EUR (with "Productivity" which might not be guaranteed). And since Stansted Captain salary is lower, i would suggest that Stansted FO salaries would be lower too. Additionally, other bases in southern Europe might be even worse.
Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by ainiriand on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @05:35AM (#18440008)
You are right, the figures are misleading and do not represent EU pilot salaries. Apologies for the error.
Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by apexalpha on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @04:05AM (#18439663)
>I'm hearing pilots get massively underpaid for the responsibility they have,

I think this is outdated from the post-2008 crisis time, when Airlines cut back on flights. Currently there is a massive shortage of pilots, some make 150k ~ 300k in the Middle East of China.

Re:Boeing Withheld Information on 737 Model, According to Sa... by zhte415 on Tuesday November 13, 2018 @06:50AM (#18440288)
According to this [0], there's quite some caveat for airline pilots in China.

I was going to quote parts of it, but it's all quite insightful that, making 150k-300k is not quite how it goes. Take a read.

[0] https://onemileatatime.com/expat-pilots-in-asia/