News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by xlnt on Thursday May 08, 2008 @02:36AM (#184269)
I don't think he owes anything to society. I think he should do what's best for himself. If that's pokemon, so be it, but he'd be better off, and live a better life, if he cared more about thinking and learning and doing great things. Good ways of life reward the doer most of all.
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by izak30 on Thursday May 08, 2008 @02:00PM (#184795)
This is completely contradictory to your original argument. Your original argument was 'if you can do "better" and you're not-> you are guilty of having immoral values' Completely neglecting the subjectivity of morality, this statement above says that he should do what is best for himself, even if that is pokemon or football (citing your examples only..nothing wrong with pokemon or football), and I think the only global definition of morality is what one 'should do' (with a different set of rules in each subset definition).
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by xlnt on Thursday May 08, 2008 @02:24PM (#184831)
i don't see how you can call my position contradictory just b/c you disagree that morality is objective. that's not an internal contradiction -- i consistently consider it objective.
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by izak30 on Thursday May 08, 2008 @03:37PM (#184921)
'completely neglecting the subjectivity of morality' <--I did not disagree with you on this, I assumed your position.
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by xlnt on Thursday May 08, 2008 @04:19PM (#184953)
what is the contradiction you are saying that my position contains?
Re:Ask YC: What's the best advice you ever got? by trekker7 on Thursday May 08, 2008 @03:00AM (#184277)
Yeah, I can definitely agree with that dude. The doctor's life might be overall better if he finds a way to enjoy it.