Re:FSF marks commons clause as non-free, recommends users fo...
by roenxi on Sunday November 11, 2018 @01:48AM
(#18425298)
I don't know there is any controversy as such. The FSF is doing its job and reminding everyone that freedom includes the freedom to make money.
If your software is licensed under something that includes the Commons Clause then it isn't free software, because users are not free to do what they want with it (being limited by the Commons Clause, funnily enough).
I'd hazard the only reason this is worth a mention is because "Commons Clause" sounds a lot like "Creative Commons" and, as the article mentions, it is a also misleading because it is attached to licenses in a way that changes them from Free Software licenses to [-O-p-e-n-S-o-u-r-c-e- +] proprietary software licenses. Someone scanning the license could think "oh, this is xyz license that is free, all is good" and not pick up on the Commons Clause. It is a bit insidious like that.
If your software is licensed under something that includes the Commons Clause then it isn't free software, because users are not free to do what they want with it (being limited by the Commons Clause, funnily enough).
I'd hazard the only reason this is worth a mention is because "Commons Clause" sounds a lot like "Creative Commons" and, as the article mentions, it is a also misleading because it is attached to licenses in a way that changes them from Free Software licenses to [-O-p-e-n-S-o-u-r-c-e- +] proprietary software licenses. Someone scanning the license could think "oh, this is xyz license that is free, all is good" and not pick up on the Commons Clause. It is a bit insidious like that.
+ EDIT - Scratch that, it isn't even open source.