Tightly integrated hardware, and efforts to develop software that improves performance of long-discontinued products does a lot to explain why Apple products are used much longer than alternatives. Compare a Mac mini to a budget mini tower, and it is difficult to argue that attaching an external Thunderbolt 3 drive in 2024 is worse for the environment, when the competing product will likely be in a landfill, due to difficult to diagnose hardware issues and there not being an easily understood recycling program.
I started recommending against in 2014 and nothing I have seen since has given me any reason to change my mind.
1. The MacOS premium. It's impractical to run MacOS on anything else.
2. Status symbol.
Anecdotally, I see a lot of people outside of HN comparing their experiences with the quality of a $1200+ USD Macbook to ~$500 USD laptops of other OEMs. Of course the Macbook wins over things half its price.
Personally I've had great experiences with Thinkpads and Latitudes, which have held up great and are very easy to repair or upgrade.
Apple makes amazing things. I would love something as slick as a Mac laptop,but I can't make myself get one.
Old Mac Minis didn't hold their value because they were upgradeable.
All macs hold their value longer.
[1] https://www.apple.com/support/macbookpro-videoissues/ [2] https://support.apple.com/en-my/iphone/repair/service/batter...
This isn't the early 2000s. The Mac Mini has an SSD, and for the overwhelming majority of these machines it will easily outlive their useful life.
I was immediately dismayed to see that storage is not upgradeable/replaceable ... but now that the device has USB3 ports, would it not be possible to boot, and run, in a performant manner, from a USB3 thumb drive ?
It seems to me that you should be able to keep these new USB3 minis in service "forever" with a little nub sticking out the back ...
I guess I don't know what the state of installing OSX to boot from external media is, circa High Sierra ... ?
Much faster than the real slow hdd it came with at least, plus I don't have to open it up to clear out the data when I'm finally done with it.
I still have yet to figure out how to create a similar hassle-free "live" booting environment which works across various hardware for windows and linux.
What happens when the soldered-on SSD fails? Can you alter a setting in the PRAM or SMC to let the system completely disregard the failed SSD?
Also on the documentation of the T2 chip, Apple strongly recommends to use file vault, because if you do not, the ssd even though it is encrypted by default, gets decrypted [1] upon being mounted.
To sum up, I guess it is possible to boot from whatever device you want.
What is the speed difference between the on-board PCIe connected SSD vs. the USB3 connected SSD ? Aren't both PCIe and USB3 faster than the SSD, making it the bottleneck ?
A flash drive would, of course, be terribly slow ... do they make USB "thumb drives" that are SSD (not flash) ?
What happens three years down the line when the device is out of warranty and the storage fails? Between paying an absurd amount of money to replace the whole board and getting a new one I bet most people will go with the landfill option.
My Mac mini 2012 got a second life after I maxed out the ram and replaced the spinning rust. If a component fails I can easily replace it and squeeze a couple of years more out of it.