News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by alanh on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:15PM (#1840479)
> “We can’t build it for the iPhone because it wouldn’t make it past the App Store approval process,” Mr. Tanjeloff said.

The app is, by definition, spyware. It secretly, continuously forwards all SMS messages to a third party, and “there is no visible icon or shortcut to access it.”

It’s like an ad for iPhone.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by jamesbritt on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @07:58PM (#1841024)
" It secretly, continuously forwards all SMS messages to a third party, ..."

It's only secret if you're not the one who installed it.

I think of spyware as apps that claim to be for one thing but instead (or also) do some remote reporting that I, as the installer, would never approve of had I known. This, though, is called Secret SMS Replicator.

If I had a need to spy on my children (perhaps I was concerned over who they might be texting) this would be quite handy.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by alanh on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @08:33PM (#1841127)
It is unethical to use this software on one’s children without letting them know. Not to mention hypocritical if one’s purpose is moral instruction (in giving them a phone, its implied purpose is communication to parties of their choosing, not to someone and mom/dad; installing this software is deceitful).

Some consider communication technology almost like “soft cybernetics.” By that line if thinking, secretly reading every SMS is like tapping into your children’s mind. This may be desirable but I would consider that a violation of their own right to privacy and personhood, and (mild) psychological abuse.

But this whole discussion is on the usefulness of SMS forwarding, which is orthogonal to the security & privacy issues of the original article, and the implied endorsement of a quality App Store.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by spokey on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @09:53PM (#1841351)
> It is unethical to use this software on one’s children without letting them know.

I disagree. If you had written "spouse" or "significant other" or really any other adult I'd agree with you, but I don't think you can make that absolute statement when it comes to (minor) children.

Letting the child know about the monitoring software would be the good and trusting thing to do, but "unethical" overstates the case significantly. I can imagine cases where it would reflect poor judgment or be inappropriate to snoop in this way, but I can readily imagine scenarios where it would be unethical NOT to secretly monitor a child's communication.

Part of a parent's job is to keep their children out of trouble until the child is old enough to do that for themselves. (Another part, as you suggest, is teaching the child how to do just that.) Absolute statements about privacy kind of go out the window when you are talking about a relationship and responsibility of that nature.

It is not hard to imagine a child (not every child, but certainly some, especially in the "tween" age range) that has the capacity and desire to hide some communication from his or her parents but lacking the judgment and life-skills to keep themselves safe from harm when doing so.

Suppose your child is engaged in inappropriate or damaging behavior such bullying/being bullied, involved in self-harm/cutting, drug abuse, illegal activities, or things even more sinister. If your child has the desire to hide that activity from you, you could tell your child about the monitoring software but then they'll be careful to find another channel to communicate about this activity. Alternatively you could not tell them about the software and have some additional insight into their world whether they want you to have it or not.

Look, it wouldn't be my first course of action, I wouldn't do it without provocation, and I would be very very careful how I made use of the information, but I wouldn't hesitate to violate my minor child's privacy if I thought it was important to protecting her well being. Monitoring text messages is nothing, I'd read her diary if necessary.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by jimbojohn on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:16PM (#1841416)
So moral absolutes apply to adults but not children? There is never a case when spying on an adult could save their life?

I'm not sure about your examples. If you suspect your child may be suicidal, talk to him or her. If you do NOT suspect bullying or cutting, how do you know that spying is justified? I think you're "begging the question."

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by spokey on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @11:27PM (#1841580)
That's a bit of a strawman, I'm pretty sure that's not what I said.

This much I know: an absolute right to privacy does not apply to children.

Like you I mean this in the ethical sense: there are (IMO) beyond doubt cases where it is ethical for a custodial parent to invade the privacy of a child, possibly without the child's knowledge or consent. But I suspect this is also a legal fact virtually everywhere, which suggests to me that this may not be a controversial perspective.

I'd be surprised to find and interested in understanding the perspective of a parent that disagrees.

This seems like a no-brainer to me: at some stage kids just aren't capable of managing their own lives. I would take action to stop my (hypothetical) 13-year-old child from cutting just as I would take action to stop my 3-year-old child from playing with knives. The actions would be different. Talking about it would certainly be a preferred option, probably the preferred option, in dealing with the 13-year-old. If it came to monitoring, telling the child that their communication will be monitored would be preferable to not telling them. But I certainly wouldn't just throw up my hands as say "c'est la vie" if those things didn't work and I certainly wouldn't hesitate to invade the child's privacy if I thought it would have a positive impact in the long run.

I did not and cannot make a universal statement about "moral absolutes", only about the "right to privacy".

Personally I'm not sure whether or not an absolute right to privacy applies to adults. You make one argument against it (for their own protection). Personally I disagree with that, I think that if you are a mentally competent adult eventually society has to give you the flexibility to harm yourself if you choose to, but I can understand where that argument is coming from. There are other arguments against an absolute right to privacy that I think are more widely accepted, such violating an adult's privacy for the protection of others, but that's a slippery slope to go down.

Also, re:

> If you do NOT suspect bullying or cutting, how do you know that spying is justified?

one of us must be misunderstanding the other. I'm in 100% agreement with you. If I did not suspect an issue that could be helped by "spying", I wouldn't be doing it.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by sigzero on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:31PM (#1841452)
It is a fine line to me to say a parent is spying on one of their children. That said, I would probably let my child know.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by sprout on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @06:44PM (#1840778)
How difficult is it to jailbreak an iPhone, install a trojan, and then make it superficially at least unjailbroken?

At the least steps 1 & 2 ought to be pretty easy.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by jimbojohn on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @07:28PM (#1840928)
An up-to-date iPhone is not trivial to jailbreak, especially if it isn't yours. Jailbreaking is a specific kind of rooting. It "ought" to be virtually impossible.

Then good luck hiding your trail, reassociating the Apple ID, hoping no apps broke due to the jailbreak (it's happened to me), keeping the device associated with the owner's iTunes, etc.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by aikinai on Thursday October 28, 2010 @01:44AM (#1841902)
There are times when jailbreaking an up-to-date iPhone is not possible, but right now the latest firmware can be rooted in a few minutes with a very simple program. It does not affect your Apple ID, iTunes association or anything other apps. It just gives you root access and installs the jailbroken app store from which you can install OpenSSH, etc.

I'm not sure if there are any trojans available, but if there were, you could easily install them and then either delete the jailbroken app store or just hide it from SpringBoard.

This process could easily be done in 10-15 minutes as long as you have physical access to the phone.

Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by mattmcknight on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @11:23PM (#1841568)
Yeah, on iPhone the spouse just needs access to your computer. http://www.iphone-sms.com/
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by alanh on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @11:26PM (#1841578)
Well that’s certainly an eye-opening use case of that software. I understand that setting the iTunes preference “Encrypt iPhone backups” and/or not allowing your spouse to log in as you would cover stop this. And deleting SMSes before syncing would also shield them from these, I assume.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by stevenwei on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:43PM (#1840581)
I wonder how long it'll take for an exploit to come along that automatically installs this type of stuff on people's phones?
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by johnrob on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:49PM (#1840599)
It may be spyware, but I'd still like the option of installing it if I want to. Nobody every said freedom came without flaws.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by the-kenny on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:55PM (#1840622)
You could install it, Android allows software installation without the Market. It should just not get distributed through the Market. It's Spyware.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by thwarted on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @06:14PM (#1840685)
It's more of a tradeoff or limit than a flaw. Flaw implies, in some sense, that flawless and perfection is possible.
Re:Android App Secretly Forwards Text Messages by yanw on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @06:33PM (#1840746)
I'm the only one who knows the password + swipe pattern to unlock my phone so I'm the only one who installs apps on it, plus all apps are listed if you decide to check your installed app inventory.