Re:The Strong Free Will Theorem (2009) [pdf]
by sooheon on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @08:14PM
(#18403691)
I agree pre-determination is orthogonal to the question. If the state machine has a truly random component, pre-determination goes out the window.
> [...] if we remove the prior state modifier from the generate state function then the core piece that is left over is "your basest existence".
I think removing the prior state modifier leaves you with nothing. A brain with no prior state is a brain with absolutely no memories, knowledge, or stored procedures. Even if such a brain were possible to construct, plasticity would ensure that unless it was dead, it would immediately begin accumulating prior state with which to make subsequent choices.
> [...] if we remove the prior state modifier from the generate state function then the core piece that is left over is "your basest existence".
I think removing the prior state modifier leaves you with nothing. A brain with no prior state is a brain with absolutely no memories, knowledge, or stored procedures. Even if such a brain were possible to construct, plasticity would ensure that unless it was dead, it would immediately begin accumulating prior state with which to make subsequent choices.