News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by hunta2097 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:22AM (#18389481)
With so much hate for Oracle, how long before they crash?

It's not like the hate for Apple, Microsoft or Google (which have enclaves of distrust) - in my experience Oracle seems universally hated.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by bayindirh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:37AM (#18389555)
We've bought some of their high end ZFS boxes. While I cannot comment for the hardware and experience (I temporarily left the team after we bought the HW), during the buying process I gained some valuable insight about them.

It looks like, unlike Apple, Microsoft or Google they are motivated solely by the money. Not the monopoly, not the domination, not the technology, just the money.

If they can earn the same amount of money, without doing anything, they will happily do that. Yes, they have very good technologies, but they are just built for the money.

Every corporation is in for the money, but money is generally a byproduct of good services and technologies, however it's backwards for Oracle. Services, products, and technologies are a byproduct of money. Money is not needed for products. Products are needed for money.

This is why Oracle is used also as an acronym for Larry Ellison's character and material wealth.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by curt15 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:10AM (#18391651)
See also this VP's blog post https://seclists.org/isn/2015/Aug/4 which reinforces Oracle's worst stereotypes
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by hunta2097 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:00PM (#18395268)
Wow - that's shockingly tone-deaf.

He's virtually goading people into releasing discoveries to the public first (but of course they have already discovered these bugs and the fix was ready anyway - so THERE!).

Aren't we past the days when decompiling code would offer any real advantage?

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by jsight on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:18PM (#18395414)
In his defense, there is a real problem with people running code analysis tools and assuming the results to be correct. It can be difficult to deal with a constant barrage of incorrect "security findings".

It still doesn't excuse some of the things said in that post, though, of course.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by bayindirh on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @03:42AM (#18397851)
I think he's doing his job very, very well [0]. The vulnerability in linked post is disclosed directly to the public.

[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18395855

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by jarnix on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:52AM (#18390923)
"One Rich American Called Larry Ellison"
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by DannyB2 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:37AM (#18391914)
I heard that acronym expansion with a different A-word which ends with 'hole'.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by acct1771 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @03:30PM (#18394669)
Tangentially topical, fuck censorship, "asshole" is what people were calling him.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by manishsharan on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:03AM (#18389937)
While that is true, I am under the impresssion OpenJDK project is mostly Oracle developers
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by pron on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @10:12AM (#18391669)
That is correct. Oracle funds ~90% of OpenJDK development, and will continue to contribute most of the security patches (just not backport them).
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by jacques_chester on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @07:29AM (#18390376)
There'll be a diaspora soon enough, as other companies beef up on their OpenJDK rosters to bolster credibility in the face of Oracle FUD.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by auslander on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @06:52AM (#18390142)
> unlike Apple, Microsoft or Google they are motivated solely by the money

Unlike Google? What other motivations Google have? MS and Apple have solid products (hardware and Office/Windows). What Google have?

I'd risk to say, any business is motivated solely by money :) The differentiator is what and how are they selling. Oracle sucks in the 'how' department. Google sucks in 'what' department - phishing for people's data mostly, and selling it to businesses.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by faceplanted on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @08:37AM (#18390831)
I think what he's implying is that they don't ever start with a product idea without a monetisation strategy or customers, like Google have done a few different times now.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by Barrin92 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:37PM (#18395556)
That might be true but I don't exactly see what's wrong with that? After all by identifying what is going to be financially successful they are very much trying to serve the demands that people have on the market.

If anything not enough companies actually ask themselves if there is a market for their product, and instead spent a lot of manhours on building products around 'ideas', when at the end of the day someone actually needs to buy your stuff.

That last part isn't the side-effect of a business, it's what it's about, and it generally makes both consumers and businesses better off.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by bayindirh on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @01:12AM (#18397412)
By experience, I divide the businesses / businessmen into two main groups. First group is motivated by serving the demands and needs of the market, and they earn money as a result. Second group wants to earn money, and they earn money by trying to serve the market's demand or by bullying people into buying their products.

First group earns way more money, produces way more higher quality goods, and people are happy to work with them, because don't feel ripped off or short changed. The second group makes you feel ripped off, produces inferior products and never supports you if something goes wrong.

Earning money is a side-effect for the first group. Yes, they earn money, but since they provide quality goods or services, they earn money without effort. For the second group since earning money is the primary target, they don't care about the products they provide unless the money stops flowing.

I didn't intend to imply that business shall be free. I tried to say that good business inevitably brings money in, and Oracle doesn't provide good business to earn money. They just want your money, and give you something in return to act as a memorial item and as an instrument to get more money from you.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by bayindirh on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:03AM (#18391005)
@faceplanted, exactly that. Thanks for the clarification.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by mhd on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:07AM (#18389695)
If hate could crash Oracle, the site of its corporate headquarters would’ve been a giant “crack of doom” since the early 90s. The enterprise world runs on a different strata of popularity.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by akadruid1 on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @04:42AM (#18389582)
They won't crash while they are trusted by the small cohort of decision makers in the "Enterprise" software market.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by brobdingnagians on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:26AM (#18389784)
This is exactly correct. The guy I work for has friend who does sales at Oracle; as soon as he mentioned to his friend that he was starting a software company, the friend started telling him that Oracle was needed to make sure our data didn't get "corrupted" and started blaming random problems on not having Oracle; so the guy I work for started asking me if we needed to move to Oracle immediately and front the money for it. I was like, "hell no", we are a very small company, no need to pay a huge licensing fee just for a database that won't make a bit of difference to our customers... but he still sometimes floats the idea.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by asien on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @05:46AM (#18389852)
> telling him that Oracle was needed to make sure our data didn't get "corrupted" and started blaming random problems on not having Oracle;

It is and it has always been Oracle and Larry Ellison to dump on others tech to promote his own.[0]

Now you know why enterprise love Oracle so much.

[0] https://youtu.be/xrzMYL901AQ

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by z3t4 on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:12AM (#18397984)
Wow, that guys is really good at hustling. Truth is very few people are technically well-grounded enough to audit the differences between two database solutions. And the solution(s) being closed source make it even harder. For the same reasons there exist literally no independent comparisons to different database solutions. So the choice will be highly fashionable, eg. based on how good you will look, rather then the qualities in the materials and handcraft.
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by EliRivers on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @04:53AM (#18398121)
Not everyone has someone as convincing as you, it seems: https://thedailywtf.com/articles/A-Software-Problem,-A-Marke...
Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by sonnyblarney on Tuesday November 06, 2018 @09:06AM (#18391037)
"It's not like the hate for Apple, Microsoft or Google"

This is not about love or hate, it's about how much value they provide and at what cost.

Yes, they spend a lot of money convincing execs that they need Oracle, but they actually do have a good product. And don't discount all the other things like support etc.. In many applications, the cost of a DB is simply not hugely material.

So I don't like them, don't care for them, Ellison is one of the bigger douche bags around. But I'd still buy their product if it made sense to.

Re:Re-affirming Long-Term Support for Java in Amazon Linux by jpatokal on Wednesday November 07, 2018 @05:17AM (#18398208)
Genuine question: is Oracle actually still superior to alternative solutions these days?

I used to work with Oracle in my telco days, and RAC in particular was a nightmare to deal with. But then as now, the standard defense used to be "oh, the product is actually great, you just need to get set up right by one of the 3 Oracle DBAs on the planet who know what they're doing".