I guess South Park is like the Simpsons now... There's literally an episode for every situation.
But the pragmatism of: they were a member of X party during Y election is a very close proxy to 'how they voted' - moreover, the motivation of the app makers is still oriented towards the publishing of essentially private information i.e. voting orientation.
Which is not helpful.
I believe Americans are far less extreme than the pop culture news outlets (basically almost all cable news) would have us believe. If you check Pew polling there is actually wide consensus on a lot of issues which see partisan but are really not.
https://verokone.hs.fi/henkilo/1978Paananen%20Ilkka%20Matias https://verokone.hs.fi/henkilo/1962Widenius%20Ulf%20Michael
And just because they are public doesn't mean it isn't a bad idea to make them easily available.
In Scandinavian countries I think you can look up someone's income tax - but it's a little bit bureaucratic and that person will also be notified that you looked them up. Not sure if it's necessary, but the sharing logic is necessary.
If you want to know how someone voted, you have to pay $5 for each person, they will be notified, and you can't publish the information, or something like that.
Or better yet - it should be confidential.