Re:Ask HN: I built it, "they" didn't come...
by sjs382 on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @11:04AM
(#1838888)
1. Ah! With that link, it's because the attribute isn't in quotes. I'll fix that right away!
2. There is a submit button. The "isn't Short" image is a button. I'll fix that soon. Also, I'll add a progress bar. Is that something that's really detracting from people using the site, though?
3. How would you restructure the blog post about it?
Re:Ask HN: I built it, "they" didn't come...
by pornel on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @12:15PM
(#1839208)
Button should look like a button (have affordance). "isn't short" is not a good label — it's not a command (you isn't short URLs?).
If button gives click feedback and you can shorten in 1-2 seconds, then you might not need a progress bar.
Explain on the page, in something that can be read in 4 seconds, what is that any why should anybody use it (problems you solve that others don't).
Assume nobody reads the blog post.
UI is a bit weird — there is no submit button, no progress for the magic ajaxy thing.
Page that explains what it's about starts with mix of obviousness and downsides.