News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Epik welcomed Gab.com by lliamander on Monday November 05, 2018 @05:22PM (#18386531)
By reducing the totality of the human experience of suffering to a single quantity, you give your ethical framework the patina of objectivity. However, without an instrument that could actually measure this quantity, any governance structure based on your framework would be at the mercy of sophists, pity mongers, and empathy traps.
Re:Why Epik welcomed Gab.com by sagichmal on Monday November 05, 2018 @05:38PM (#18386648)
> However, without an instrument that could actually measure this quantity, any governance structure based on your framework would be at the mercy of . . .

All systems -- government, financial, computer -- are social systems, in that they're built with human beings as the foundation, and not the other way around.

Because humans are subjective, squishy, and imprecise, it follows naturally and unavoidably that systems built on top of us need to accommodate those properties as invariants. They should not (because they can not) presume their foundation as some kind of objective, fixed, precise spherical cow of uniform density.

Yes, measurement of suffering is subjective. No, that's not a reason to avoid doing it. It's precisely that subjectivity which makes the systems built on top of it sound.