That's quite interesting. Most of the people visiting our site come from other marketing channels and are (at least looking at the heatmaps and a/b testing results) generally checking us out.
Have you got a link to one of your sites with the step signup process?
Our marketing channel is usually word of mouth; so "sign up" works quite well. It is essentially "email us but with tactile feedback". We are in the same sector - but the product/services are somewhat different (along the lines of "help help we have a serious problem save us yesterday") so the demographic is probably fairly different.
And traffic from the sites are relatively low compared to someone being given our phone #, so it might have skewed data.
Unfortunately I can't really share more than that publicly (employers choice, not mine). But feel free to email me if you want (address in profile).
We are in the same sector and have had great success with the "step signup" process - i.e. contact forms.
YMMV. But mid-range corporates feel happy about such things.
Random observation; but for anything related to corporate purchasing the more finicky you make it (within reason) the better it is liked. Middle managers are overjoyed to ring you up, ask for a costing, then ring again for an invoice and finally a third time to give you card details.