News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by singular on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @09:13AM (#1838396)
Risking downvotes but here I go anyway...

It's interesting to compare his theory against the country where his theories were first, and arguably most purely put into practice - Pinochet-era Chile.

The measures put forward by Friedman + his acolytes resulted in huge unemployment, inflation, and many multi-nationals effectively stealing wealth away.

In order for the people to 'accept' these measures Pinochet instituted oppression, abandonment of the freedom of the press, torture, and extra-judicial killings.

I think the ideas which originate from the creator of neo-liberalism ought to be judged against the evidence of its actual implementation in real life before recommending its architect's theories on dealing with just about anything.

The laws that were passed in Chile, as with many other countries which have instituted exactly the policies you outline were widely disrespected, and that disrespect was 'dealt with' in various arguably really rather negative ways.

I am certain that corruption also remained a problem throughout.

For references and discussion of this phenomenon, see The Shock Doctrine by Naomi Klein - http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0141024534/

Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by anamax on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @09:56AM (#1838592)
> I think the ideas which originate from the creator of neo-liberalism ought to be judged against the evidence of its actual implementation in real life before recommending its architect's theories on dealing with just about anything.

Fair enough. China, Cuba, the USSR....

Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by singular on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @09:58AM (#1838602)
> Fair enough. China, Cuba, the USSR....

Hardly wonderful examples of corruption-free parts of the world!!

Or ought there be a sarcasm indicator in that message? :)

Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by anamax on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @04:56PM (#1840416)
I'm not referring to corruption, but suggesting that we can apply the "I think the ideas which originate from the creator of neo-liberalism ought to be judged against the evidence of its actual implementation in real life before recommending its architect's theories on dealing with just about anything." to communism/socialism.

Of course, that standard is always rejected when it comes to communism/socialism.

Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by singular on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:03PM (#1840435)
I absolutely apply the same standard to communism, socialism or any political/economic system.

There are alternatives to extremes, which both communism and neoliberalism can safely be described as I think - a Keynesian approach has a great deal of evidence in the positive behind it (the new deal for example), and I am sure he has had (I know far too little to comment myself) opinions on corruption.

Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by galisevych on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:02AM (#1838615)
USSR? isn't it fall apart in 1991 with rest of soviet union?
Re:What a Rotten World It Can Be: Report Says Three-Fourths ... by loewenskind on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:51AM (#1838833)
The best part was that their horrid changes caused a massive productivity drop. They had to wait several years before gaining a modest 5% growth rate (was 7% before they started meddling) at which point they wrote a book called "Miracle of Chile"!