When Facebook started, it was just people, a couple pictures, their contact info, their classes, and a Wall. There was no messaging or News Feed. It really wasn't much of a social network at all compared to what it is today.
I would argue that some sites benefit from having a non-specific domain name. If Google had been searchengine.com, maps.searchengine.com and mail.searchengine.com seem a bit weird. Having a less specific name allows a company to pivot without changing its branding.
Re:I Buy and Sell Domain Names AMA
by ultrasaurus on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:46AM
(#1838809)
For Google it might even hurt them at this point. Lots of users don't know their browser, but they know that Google=Internet. "Yahoo Search Engine" would be a lot more competitive with "Search Engine" from a branding perspective.
yep, totally.
Likewise if amazon had been called books.com they'd have a hard time diversifying into the huge repertoire they have now. The same's true of just about any popular site you care to mention. What does flickr mean? del.icio.us? What does ycombinator have to do with startups? etc etc etc.
Amazon is a much better example than the one I used.
Re:I Buy and Sell Domain Names AMA
by aberkowitz on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @10:00AM
(#1838609)
In this case, google has a catchy two syllable name and a twelve year-old product that outpaces the competition in accuracy and design.
I fail to see how Facebook is anything but a brilliant name. It is easy to remember and describes the physical implementation of the site.
If your business has real value, the domain name is not relevant at all. Look at the top startups. How many of them have "keyword rich" domains that are relevant to their business?
Of course you can argue that this is an effect of domain squatters, but I would argue that the fact they couldn't get their first choice of domain name has had no discernible impact on these businesses.