Re:1 in 4 Statisticians Say They Were Asked to Commit Scient...
by BeetleB on Saturday November 03, 2018 @02:25PM
(#18371683)
This issue comes up often on HN, and it used to a lot in /r/science (maybe it still does - I left that subreddit years ago).
If there's one thing I could convey to the world from what I learned from my time in academia, it is this: Most scientists at universities do not care about reproducibility.[1] Not only that, many people intentionally omit details from papers so that it is hard for rivals to reproduce their work - they want the edge so they can publish without competition. This isn't a shadowy conspiracy theory - this is what advisors openly tell their students. Search around on HN and reddit and you'll see people saying it.
[1] My experience is in condensed matter physics - it may not apply to all of academia.
If there's one thing I could convey to the world from what I learned from my time in academia, it is this: Most scientists at universities do not care about reproducibility.[1] Not only that, many people intentionally omit details from papers so that it is hard for rivals to reproduce their work - they want the edge so they can publish without competition. This isn't a shadowy conspiracy theory - this is what advisors openly tell their students. Search around on HN and reddit and you'll see people saying it.
[1] My experience is in condensed matter physics - it may not apply to all of academia.