I think everything is just fine. I take away a lot of good stuff from this board everyday, and get good intelligent responses from other users. And this is probably the only place I have ever encountered where people willingly admit their mistakes and change their views if they are intelligently countered. This is a very good thing.
It doesn't seem to me the stories are any worse now than they were at first. The quality went down a bit a few weeks ago when we were mentioned on Techcrunch and got a lot of new users, but it seems back up now. I suppose I should write something to display the top stories from the past to make sure this is true.