Suppose Alice is the CEO and Bob is the CPO. Their minions produce the annual privacy report, and give it to Alice and Bob to certify and send to the FTC.
Alice and Bob both know that the report does not meet the legal requirements.
Alice and Bob nevertheless both certify it and it is sent to the FTC.
I don't see what Alice and Bob could do different from each other that could lead to one of them being liable for "intentionally certifying" the bad report and the other being liable for merely "certifying" it.
Compare to, say, killing a pedestrian by driving through a crosswalk that you know is occupied. It would then make sense to distinguish between
• driving through a crosswalk that you knew to be occupied, and
• intentionally driving through a crosswalk that you knew to be occupied.
You could do the former by seeing that the crosswalk is occupied, intending to stop when you got closer, getting distracted by something, and losing track of where you are.
The intentionally modifier makes sense there because you can unintentionally drive through a crosswalk that you know is occupied.
With certifying a report...what? You were not planning on signing the certification, but your secretary accidentally put it in a pile of things awaiting your routine signature and you signed it without realizing what it was?
There is an annual report that the company must file with the FTC. That report must be accompanied by a written statement from the CEO, the chief privacy officer, and the chief information security officer certifying that the report fully complies with section 5(a) of the Consumer Data Protection Act.
The criminal penalties for those three officers arises if they so certify the report knowing that the report does not comply.
What confuses me is that there are two levels of possible penalties.
The first level is if one of those officers "certifies any statement as set forth in subsections (b) and (c) of this section knowing that the annual report accompanying the statement does not comport with all the requirements set forth in this section".
That can subject them to up $1 million or 5% of their largest annual compensation of the past 3 years (whichever is bigger) and/or up to 10 years in jail.
The second level ups those limits to $5 million, 25%, and 20 years. The conditions for the second are word for word the same as the first level except the word "intentionally" is inserted before "certifies" so it becomes "intentionally certifies any statement..." instead of "certifies any statement...".
I'm having trouble seeing how an officer could run afoul of the first without running afoul of the second. How do you certify the report without intentionally certifying it?
At first I thought the distinction was going to be whether or not the officer knew the report was bad, but no, both cases require that the officer knows that the report is bad. The lower penalties are for certifying a report you know is bad. The higher penalties are for intentionally certifying a report you know is bad, so the distinction is whether or not the certification is intentional.