News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Modeling Message Queues in TLA+ by pwnna on Thursday November 01, 2018 @06:36PM (#18359090)
I find that learning raw TLA+ to the point where you're comfortable reading it and internalizing what the spec is saying to be a critical skill to be able to write specifications successfully. This is because PlusCal translates directly to TLA+, which means that:

1. To debug errors given to me by TLC, I generally find that it's easier to look at the TLA+ spec directly.

2. It is sometimes easier to see what your algorithm is doing directly in TLA+. I find that I will write the algo in PlusCal, it gets translated, and I can get a better understanding of how the system works by looking at the TLA+ spec. Example: the "process model" of PlusCal does hide some of the ideas. Multiple process are just P1 \/ P2 \/ P3 ....,

3. There are some oddities within PlusCal (label placement, the with statements) that makes much more sense if you understand the TLA+ foundation.

What I really wish is that I can write partly PlusCal and partly TLA+ for maximum flexibility. However, it's kinda ackward to do within the current framework.

Re:Modeling Message Queues in TLA+ by pron on Thursday November 01, 2018 @06:46PM (#18359150)
Right. In addition, you miss out on the notion of refinement (ordinary implication in TLA+) which is the most powerful (and most foundational) idea of the formalism. But I think many developers may be threatened by the unfamiliarity of TLA+, and PlusCal serves as a gateway drug, as it's often useful enough on its own (you're right that you need to know at least a bit of TLA+ to understand some of the tooling's output). If "PlusCal first" makes TLA+ less threatening and hopefully more approachable to many developers, then the approach is doing its job.

(BTW, I wouldn't call it "raw TLA+" as "raw TLA" is a particular logic that Lamport uses to introduce TLA, so the term may be confusing.)