News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by rosser on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @03:37PM (#1835716)
The fact that someone isn't wearing a belt doesn't mean they deserve a pantsing.

Perhaps not, but, to stretch your metaphor a bit, if someone's fly is open, they might appreciate having it pointed out to them.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by hugh3 on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @03:48PM (#1835756)
And how do you point it out to them? As discreetly as possible, or by shouting it to all their friends?
Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by lotharbot on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @04:01PM (#1835818)
If half of their friends also have their fly open, shouting it might be a better option.
Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by dandelany on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @04:22PM (#1835924)
I'm missing the logic here. If few people make a mistake, they should be informed privately, but if many people make a mistake, they should be shamed publicly? No.

And to be honest, I'm getting slightly tired of the community's tendency to stretch metaphors way beyond their applicability. Mine was mostly meant to add a touch of humor. Pants, flies, and underwear aside, auto-hijacking the Twitter accounts of everyone on your network is just dickish (no pun intended). Especially when the belt store is closed to everyone except the pants-manufacturers ;)

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by jontywareing on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @05:59PM (#1836296)
I do not think this can really be considered "shaming" as it's nothing to be embarrassed about.

Regarding private/public notification; Posting to your own account is an easily understandable visible demonstration of what's possible and why you should care - a DM from another account, or an @ just won't have the same effect on the user.

(I have said this elsewhere in the thread, so apologies for repetition)

I have been informed that it's possible to send a DM to yourself, so I'll add that as an option shortly as a nice alternative.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by ChRoss on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @09:59PM (#1836938)
I understand the intention is to warn people. But IMO, there are plenty ways of warning or educating them, e.g. blogs, tweets etc. There's no need to 'prove' it just to make awareness.

I did tell my friends and family that a tool (Firesheep) has been released and what is the impact in layman language, and inform them to be careful when browsing through open wifi networks.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by btilly on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @05:21PM (#1836144)
Random public shaming may not be fair, but it is a fast way to get the message out to lots of people. And I've seen it be an effective way to drive behavior change.
Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by regularfry on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @06:28AM (#1838004)
Metaphors are less effort to bike-shed than the underlying concept. Witness the undying car analogy, or the "C is a hammer" nonsense from a couple of days ago.

Yes, it's boring; yes, it's intellectually lazy and useless. No, it's not going away.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by tertius on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @04:09PM (#1835861)
You can see their friends' flies open? That's one ninja technique that I didn't want to know about.

Point is, you don't know, so don't assume.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by Groxx on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @08:05PM (#1836688)
To continue the metaphor...

They walked into a glass building (unencrypted wifi location), unzipped their flies, sat down, and are totally unaware they did so. Someone would have noticed eventually - would they rather be potentially gawked at behind the one-way mirror that's always been there but they never noticed (WireShark), or told, allowing them to cookie-block the ones who do so?

As to the volume of the telling, what if near enough to everyone were doing this? You would probably become the crazy person at the intersection, telling everyone the end of privacy is near, repent and use SSL. But at least this way you can demonstrate that yes, their flies are down, in a way they can see, rather than having to take your word on it.

Re:Firesheep usage leads to Idiocy by astine on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @04:16PM (#1835901)
If everyone's flies are open, you've wandered onto the set of a gay porno.