Re:Why I Am An Anarchist
by steveklabnik on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @02:53PM
(#1835503)
> who or what will fulfill the role that the police currently fulfill.
I touched upon this a bit; I think that the police don't have as big of a deterrent effect as you'd think. Social structures such as "I don't want to get robbed, so I don't rob others" play a much larger role.
TL;DR, most crime wouldn't exist under anarchism, because many crimes simply aren't crimes anymore. There's no incentive for someone to steal my wallet, because a small piece of leather isn't really useful.
> Hasn't society been down this road, in both micro and macro scenarios, many times before?
We have, and we still haven't found a good answer. Are you saying petty theft is nonexistent today? Plenty of people still steal wallets.
I touched upon this a bit; I think that the police don't have as big of a deterrent effect as you'd think. Social structures such as "I don't want to get robbed, so I don't rob others" play a much larger role.
This is a large and complex question, and so I'm going to bow out to the FAQ, which has a pretty in-depth discussion of this topic: http://anarchism.pageabode.com/afaq/secI5.html#seci58
TL;DR, most crime wouldn't exist under anarchism, because many crimes simply aren't crimes anymore. There's no incentive for someone to steal my wallet, because a small piece of leather isn't really useful.
> Hasn't society been down this road, in both micro and macro scenarios, many times before?
We have, and we still haven't found a good answer. Are you saying petty theft is nonexistent today? Plenty of people still steal wallets.