That is, I should go "wow!" before "awww, free is only 64", instead of the other way around.
Exactly what I was trying to say; you put it better than I did. (And your suggested fix would have worked for me too.)
Put another way - if I had built this, the main reason I would have included Google Reader import in the free version would be so people could experience the value of my app without having to think - about what blogs to subscribe to, or what existing subscriptions to keep. Putting the paywall at this point in the first user experience removes that benefit in cases like mine. I might think about the benefits of your app and come back and upgrade - or I might forget - but you could have had me as an impulse buy.
Ideally, I'd make all feeds free and updated every 5 minutes. Realistically, if I force you to choose, I can perform that much better for everybody else. It's a trade-off which I try to stack in my favor by giving the user an easy-to-use UI to activate different feeds as they choose under the standard account.
You could pay $12 a year and get unlimited feeds. That would make both of us very happy. :-)
First, just give them 64 feeds and tell them about it on some form of status bar. The "updating your feeds 63/64" progress bar, but maybe yellow with "We're only updating 64 of your feeds. [a href="why-premium/"]Why?[/a]"
Also, you can choose those 64 feeds to update as a union of what they have subscribed to and what you're currently already having to fetch, thereby making the necessary amount of work for each new user theoretically less in the best case, and no worse in the worst case.