i would wager there are plenty more films available on DVD than on downloadable format. sure the reasons for this may be stupid ... but they're reasons nonetheless [for now].
but your analogy is well-founded. convenience usually wins. and after all, laserdiscs looked much better than their competitors and still didn't survive.
In theory I could buy movies on iTunes, but I frankly don't trust anything I buy on iTunes to still work in ten years, whereas I'm pretty sure I'll still be able to get my Blu-Rays to play.
I agree that the state of marketplaces is not there yet but I also think that it won't stay this way for too much longer.
I'm over physical media. Discs are messy, damage prone, and usually they just sit collecting dust.
Don't get me wrong -- I had a great time collecting a massive amount of movies and I still spend at least 3 hours in a quality bookstore when I have the chance.
BluRay adoption is very much why the format is doomed a laserdisc/betamax death. You're somewhat lucky though -- because the encryption is compromised fully so you'll be able to extract your data to a better format down the road.
You included DVD in that list? One of these things is not like the other... I think I have six devices in this room right now which can play a DVD.
Piracy aside, what's the alternative to Blu-Ray? It's Apple or Apple, and an opportunity to have a file which plays only by the grace of Apple. No thanks.
To play things I have stored digitally it's just a matter of using the remote to access thousands of movies/tv shows stored on my network.
How long did it take you to set all that up? Do you think a less technically inclined person is going to be able to set up something like that?
Also, were all these thousands of movies and TV shows acquired legally? If not, it's hardly a solution for the average law-abiding person. If so... wow, that sounds really expensive!
You mostly only pay for what you use and the clients (AppleTV's or other media players) are rarely much over $100 each.
Storage is incredibly cheap for the things you have yourself.
It's much like the movie Gran Torino where Walt has a garage filled with tools. He aquired them over time. That is the way I have aquired media that now resides on my server.
The vast majority of people have neither the inclination nor the technical wherewithal to rip DVDs to disk.
Until every DVD that Netflix stocks has a "Play" button next to it, DVDs are going to continue to be very relevant. And even then Netflix is very US-centric, only very recently expanding into Canada, not to mention the rest of the world.
the thing i can't stand is how people are perceiving the dump of the optical drive as something revolutionary. a) the old macbook air didn't have one (a gripe for many) and b) neither do netbooks.
a little off-topic but one thing that really kills me about apple is how they're seemingly refusing to add a blu-ray option even though the standard is well-established. i would really like to have one in my mbp17. not just because i have a res (1920x1200) on the lappy that supports it, but because i also have a 27" panel that i hook my laptop into.
and this move towards "no optical drives" (likely so they can sell more HD content) is only going to solidify that among their lines in my assessment.
hmmmph.