Re:Book Review: A Philosophy of Software Design
by jpittis on Monday October 29, 2018 @09:24PM
(#18333274)
I've read his book cover to cover and have enjoyed and learnt from a number of the concepts he discusses.
That being said, after recently reading "Out of the tarpit" and being a long time Rich Hickey fan, I completely agree that the model of complexity presented by the book feels simplistic.
I can't quite put my finger on why though. Maybe cause complexity in software has a lot more to do with understanding the problem domain rather than just the structure of the code. IMO it was worth the read, but I was slightly disappointed and it was without a doubt not a be all end all reference. (And it would be unfair to expect it to be.)
The writer uses a very narrow perspective and just "assumes" all this can be generalized. One of the most recurring topics in the book is "complexity", but it is just introduced with a narrow one sentence tautological definition without offering any interesting discussion. All kinds of assumptions are taken for granted and not discussed.
So overall, the book reads so far like a bland collection of "do this, don't do that blog-posts". Papers like "Out of the tarpit", speakers like Rich Hickey, etc. offer much more interesting discussions on the topic of design and complexity, and are definitely more argumentative and "philosophical".
I even feel bad for writing something in such a negative vibe about a book. But really its pretentious title lead to such disappointment...