News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by dasil003 on Monday October 25, 2010 @11:48PM (#1832860)
I upvoted this because I think it's an interesting discussion despite the fact that I disagree.

Let me ask you this: Can you think of any online discussion boards with better discussion than HN? The reason I ask is because my its nature I think Internet discourse always devolves into a garbage as a function of community size. Another way of putting it is that you can have a good Internet community as long as it doesn't get too big. In my mind HN is a notable exception in that it is large enough that it should be complete crap, but the core values of the community have held the line longer than could normally be expected.

Even reddit or slashdot, which I would hold up as having quite a few intelligent commenters, still gets drowned out by the in-humour and mindless memetics. So despite being far from perfect, I still consider HN the best discussion on the net.

Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by lkrubner on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @01:31PM (#1835144)
dasil003, you ask "Can you think of any online discussion boards with better discussion than HN?"

I often have better conversations when I meet up with friends at a coffeeshop. For me, Hacker News is in competition with all the other things I could be doing with my time, rather than merely being in competition with other online discussions. Hacker News may be the best place online for discussing concerns relevant to startups, but it still suffers from many of the problems that all online discussions suffer from, including anonymous posting. For me, the question is whether I should engage in any online conversation that isn't directly related to work. Is it worth the effort? Every minute that I spend discussing issues online is a minute that I'm not doing other things, such as discussing similar issues with close friends of mine in real life, or writing software, or responding to personal email, or exercising, or going to a museum, etc.

Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by dasil003 on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @04:28PM (#1835956)
How is that response to my question? Obviously HN can not be anything but an online discussion forum, and it can only be judged on those merits. How you choose to spend your time is well beyond the scope of my consideration.
Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by lkrubner on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:31PM (#1840536)
It is possible that the scope of our considerations do not overlap.
Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by dasil003 on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @05:36PM (#1840548)
Yeah but I upvoted you for the sake of debate. I feel cheated.
Re:Is HN only about saying nice things about everything? by lkrubner on Wednesday October 27, 2010 @11:25PM (#1841575)
dasil003, I think Hacker News is a good online forum for discussing issues that are relevant to startups.