Personally, what I see is a lot of AI becoming commoditized. There was a time when you had to have a fairly strong understanding of compilers to program anything complicated. These days you can use a high-level programming language and never get down to the level of the compiler if you don't want to.
If someone wants to make lots of money or change the world with AI, my advice would not necessarily be to start with a PhD. It would be to focus on understanding data, getting very good with a library, and building apps that are useful to people.
If you do that, then getting additional knowledge about the mathematics furthers your career, but your career doesn't block on acquiring that knowledge.
If you do this, you probably won't have a great of chance of working on a team at Google or Facebook improving the implementation of the AI infrastructure. Just as you probably wouldn't get a job at one of these companies optimizing the compiler if you didn't have an academic background or years of experience in compilers. But you could still work on other teams in those companies and make as much or more than those people and have a more direct impact than just making it marginally faster.
I have a PhD in pure mathematics, and I don't do ML. Getting a PhD is a particular journey, and it's not for everyone. Also, the idea of getting a PhD as a credential for industry seems a little odd to me, but that may be my personal bias.
PhD for industry is useful for research and development positions in a variety of fields. Just like companies see bachelor's degrees as proof you can stick with something for 4 years and complete it, PhD degrees are proof you can develop and implement research procedures on a long time scale.
Having taken Fast.ai's Deep Learning course, I can confidently say that their course is enough to help a software engineer with no previous AI experience build extremely powerful real-world AI applications.
Jeremy Howard (the cofounder of Fast.ai, the former president of Kaggle, and the former #1 Kaggle competitor) only has a B.A. in Philosophy. One student who started the Fast.ai course as a violinist is now working as a researcher at Google Brain. It may have been true in the past that you need many years of work to become competent at building AI, but that's not true anymore.
IMO, parent is right. It’s going the way computing did. Ie most degree programmes basically teach you how to programme. Many degrees don’t even require maths anymore.
Hype drives demand drives hiring ,... and always at the top a bunch of guys that don’t know anything about ML at all :)
I think the same is true of marketing. The number of marketers that are also good researchers is tiny.
And so on.
The common denominator is short supply, high demand pressure, and in all I’m thankful for it because it keeps the wolf from the door for many of us.
But.. it leaves the deeper science/art (whatever yours be) untapped , and it adds so much noise to the market that gold becomes difficult to sell for peanuts.
Of course a lot of study and also applying what you learned are important. But having a PhD says very little about a person's ability to do data science or machine learning work. Especially since most phds have an extreme focus on their narrow field.
I haven’t gotten into it myself, but that is more of an interest issue.
Also, there is no data for a lot of things.
But the question is are all Ph.D equal, in my view many students fraudulently awarded Ph.D without enough rigorous work, earlier those won't get hired, but because of AI hype they get hired. Also many old PhDs brand them-self as AI expert even though they don't know much.
Hiring is still runs on hype and there are many bias (including gender bias) exists in industry.(e.g. Facebook's Mark does not like to hire 30+ people)