Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by yzmtf2008 on Saturday October 27, 2018 @05:23PM
(#18317732)
Don’t conflate this story with “banned for no reason”. There are plenty of reasons to ban Gab.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Are they doing anything illegal?
You don't have to do anyting illegal for me not to want to conduct business with you.
In most countries, yes.
But illegality is not the issue here. People simply have a right not to be associated with hate.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by tinalumfoil on Saturday October 27, 2018 @06:42PM
(#18318119)
> a right not to be associated with hate
This is neither a right in any theoretical system of human rights I've seen, nor is there any practical way to disassociate people from a basic human emotion.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by village-idiot on Saturday October 27, 2018 @08:23PM
(#18318445)
Free association implies the freedom to not associate. You can’t make people be associated with hate groups.
Also, don’t be cute about “hate”. We aren’t talking about the human emotion and you know it.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by tinalumfoil on Saturday October 27, 2018 @09:07PM
(#18318591)
In the context of this conversation people don't have the right to disassociate with anyone they don't like. I'm not being "cute" about hate, and whatever you think hate is isn't relevant to my point. People simply do not have the right to do business with others chosen entirely from their own personal discretion. The US government can and does force businesses to provide services, at the risk of that business's existence, to unsavory entities.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by village-idiot on Saturday October 27, 2018 @09:36PM
(#18318681)
Affiliation with a hate group is not a protected characteristic.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by VectorLock on Saturday October 27, 2018 @05:40PM
(#18317828)
Do they have to be?
Banning Gab is an attack on Free Speech.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by happytoexplain on Saturday October 27, 2018 @06:12PM
(#18317998)
I strongly believe that it's not.
If PayPal bans Gab because they dislike the speech available on Gab, it is literally an attack on Free Speech. I understand you feel differently.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by vanderreeah on Saturday October 27, 2018 @06:33PM
(#18318080)
I don't know what Gab is, or what its typical content is like, though I'm getting an idea from the replies to this tweet. But the principle of free speech has nothing to do with the right of a company to use Paypal's services. It's to do with the right of individuals to say what they like without government incarcerating or otherwise harming them or their ability to speak.
If an entity stifles speech that entity is against Free Speech.
Re:Gab.com banned from PayPal
by village-idiot on Sunday October 28, 2018 @12:39AM
(#18319206)
If your belief is that PayPal doing business with Gab is free speech, you have no idea what free speech is.
PayPal isn't the government.