Yep, it’s much easier to forse yourself to do a pull up then going down on the floor for a push up in my experience too.
If I did this policy, by a frequently used door, would I end up overtrained, or would I become so strong in my arms that I could do 30-40 or so when rested? And if so, would my arms become enormous?
I'm asking because I'm somewhat interested in this policy, but....since I already do strength training and can do pullups, I'm not sure where it would lead.
(I guess I could modify it to only do pullups on workout days, 3x per week, but do them everytime I passed on those days)
First, overtraining is so hard for someone just doing normal workouts. Second, progression just doesn't work that way. I've been working for a few months towards doing 500 pull-ups in a single workout. I'm at 160 now, and I still can't do 30-40 dead hang pull-ups in one set. Finally, to become enormous you need to eat.
Considering we're talking about people who aren't doing any exercise at all for "lack of time", it's somewhat absurd to be muddying the waters talking about the opposite end of the spectrum; overtraining.
The point is to just get off your ass and do some trivial calisthenics every day before you bathe. In the early stages you're only going to be able to do a handful, maybe not even one pull-up without a chair to assist you, you're not going to "overtrain" doing as many as you possibly can in this condition: we're talking about doing very little. It's emphasized because the amount you can do is proportional to how much time it requires, it's practically zero.
In fact, the probable major result is a change in diet because of the brutal feedback attempting to lift your own weight repeatedly every morning can have.
The reality is, you require negligible amounts of time to maintain a reasonable level of phsyical fitness.
How many pushups can you do in a set? Probably so few that it requires less than one minute of time. So why aren't you doing as many pushups as you possibly can every morning before you shower? Well, simply because you don't want to, and are being lazy.
Incorporating a simple stretching and pushup routine to your daily life, once before showering, will have a significant positive impact on your wellness without costing much time.
You can add a pull-up bar to a doorway and adopt a policy of always having to do as many pull-ups as you can whenever you walk past it. I'm assuming you can't do more than one right now, so it takes almost zero time.