Re:"Calling oneself a C Programmer is like saying you're a H...
by miloshasan on Monday October 25, 2010 @04:19PM
(#1831434)
So you're saying that the "language is a tool" metaphor breaks down because C is "complete" in a way that a hammer isn't. True, but that's taking the metaphor too far; it's original meaning is that the tool matters less than what you're building.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:"Calling oneself a C Programmer is like saying you're a H...
by mturmon on Tuesday October 26, 2010 @02:07AM
(#1833239)
I was saying that the OP ("hammer carpenter") is taking the metaphor too far, which is why the phrase "hammer carpenter" sounds silly, and we seem to agree on this.
I have no problem with the conclusion that the tool matters less than what you're building.
I'd go farther and say that there is a certain tendency for C projects to "look the same" and that lispy projects "look the same" in a different way (e.g., surprisingly extensible, incorporating a language).