Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by Jaruzel on Friday October 26, 2018 @09:31AM
(#18308984)
A 'poor persons' HDR can be done with ONE good photo. Load it into a decent photo editor, and adjust the exposure down two stops and save it, then repeat again but up 2 stops. Now with the 3 copies, run it through a HDR generator. Not as good as bracketing directly in the camera, but can yield acceptable results.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by CWuestefeld on Friday October 26, 2018 @10:16AM
(#18309390)
No. This will give the visual effect of HDR (which many think is something to be avoided - HDR should be a tool, not a style), but does not increase the actual dynamic range.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by sigi45 on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:07PM
(#18310527)
It does.
My RAW Images has a higher dynamic range than the final image shows without any HDR feature.
You only put back what was already there and 'lost'.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by CWuestefeld on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:50PM
(#18310939)
That only works if you're shooting RAW. And even then all you've accomplished was a convoluted process to achieve the exact same thing you'd get in Lightroom by adjusting the Blacks and Whites sliders, and dragging the ranges horizontally in the histogram.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by sigi45 on Friday October 26, 2018 @04:50PM
(#18312616)
That does not invalidate my original statement.
I would argue that the end result should look slightly different.
But you do use more of your dynamic range
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by Jaruzel on Friday October 26, 2018 @12:02PM
(#18310462)
True, but based on the fact that hardly anyone has actual HDR capable displays, the net effect of the output is mostly the same.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by rocqua on Friday October 26, 2018 @06:49PM
(#18313272)
Really, if you are going down that road I prefer manually blending the different exposures in Photoshop. 5 years ago, that is how I dealt with bracketed exposures as well. Back then HDR still had a very definite look which I really tried to avoid.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by dr_zoidberg on Friday October 26, 2018 @08:45AM
(#18308665)
Even if you don't have/can't use a tripod , software stabilization is pretty good for handheld use. And there are a few ways you can pull that with OpenCV, so it's not that expensive editing software is involved (of course, Photoshop has it, and in a "photographer friendly way").
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by rocqua on Friday October 26, 2018 @08:52AM
(#18308713)
Stabilization deals with orientation. Location cant really be corrected for based on a 2D image.
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by dr_zoidberg on Friday October 26, 2018 @01:30PM
(#18311279)
Yes -- but it still works fine for the common distortions that a handheld camera introduces (assuming you don't go into very large time spans).
Re:HDR image to LDR using edge-preserving multiscale decompo...
by foobarrio on Friday October 26, 2018 @10:30AM
(#18309510)
I've combined hand held bracketed shots. There are problems at the edges of things due to slight shifts in location and parallax but this can be handled in photoshop and HDR (I used to use Photomatix) does a good job at removing ghosting and edge artifacts.
A smartphone without a dedicated funcion probably has too much delay between shots for HDR. Same for point-and-shoots without a tripod mount.