I got beat from my parents many times, and for the most part they were fair about it. But even after 30 plus years I still remember two instances where the punishment didn’t fit the crime and they acted on their emotion. The rest I don’t even remember.
Young kids know injustice.
In this environment, spanking was used as a proxy for these irrevocable natural consequences, to give teeth to (an often invisible to a child) danger without letting iit bite.
I'm pretty sure that the use of (comparatively insignificant) physical punishment prevented serios injuries or death multiple times.
As a child gets to 4 or 5 years old and have had time to see obvious mortal dangers avoided and the counsel of their parents validated (backed up by the minimum necessary force and ample explanation and demonstration if possible), it is rare (in my experience of child raising) that a child won't heed the counsel that they have seen proven true time and again.
As a species, we've survived eons of dangerous environments, and it wasn't due only to watchful parents.... Children are no fools once they get get to 5 or 6 years of age and can navigate dangerous environments with skill.
OTOH, when almost all of the corporal punishment I have seen doled out in public has been reactive, not well considered, and not accompanied by proper counsel, as well as with children far too old to still need that kind of correction.... So IMO it is often misused.
Bad behavior is often not a root problem, but a symptom. Spanking may be the most effective way of treating the symptom (but even that is probably a post hoc rationalization that is not factually supportable), but it mostly adds to, or at best ignores, the underlying problem. Other punitive measures also tend to ignore the problem, though they tend not to make things worse in the way that the use of physical violence does.
Sure, i am tired and stressed out sometimes and that makes actually being above thinking he's just a shit kid very hard.
I have zero recollection of this episode, but my parents tell me that when I was very young (3-5 years old, somewhere in that range) I used to sneak off an hide in malls when my parents went shopping with me, and no amount of time outs or revoked privileges could keep me from doing this (probably because the ability to punish kids through confinement or chores is limited when you're out in public with them). This extended to the point that stores had to be shut down and staff called to help search for me. My parents tell me that my dad took me to the car, explained why this behavior was unsafe and unacceptable, and that they had exhausted other disincentives before resorting to physical punishment before proceeding to spank. Supposedly when I would start to wander off my parents reminded me of the physical punishment, and clearly explained that this would be the consequence if I repeated that behavior.
Society works similarly. When people do bad things that are not exceedingly harmful we fine them or revoke privileges. Drunk driving is almost certainly more serious than kids sneaking off in malls. And we rarely apply force in that situation, preferring to fine people and revoke their driving privileges. Physical punishment in the form of imprisonment is reserved for things that are exceedingly harmful and dangerous. And when physical punishment is issue for things that aren't truly dangerous, like drugs, it's recognized as an injustice - at least by a significant chunk of society.
Siblings winding up in the ER?
Actually I wound up in the ES once come to think of it.
But being a parent now I get it. You do your best and unfortunately sometimes that's shit. I thought I would be a way better parent than I am but I try. Definitely no smacking because I worked out that at least that doesn't do anyone any good. In all my experiments of parenting so far the effective thing is making boundaries explicit and enforcing them consistently.
The hard part is consistency because kids are just relentless sometimes. But if you back down you lose. It takes patience and sometimes you just don't have it. S;me people lash out in those circumstance because the feedback is immediate and gratifying. It looks like it works.
I'm glad the data supports that while it works short term it's in aggregate more problematic long term.
While the quantitative data seems to suggest spanking is negative, the question still remains: when all other disciplinary options are exhausted, what can a parent do to stop truly intolerable behavior? The article suggests using other options, but does not list any.