Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by JustSomeNobody on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:03AM
(#18300945)
Then maybe the RDA is just wrong. If we can't eat enough healthy food to sustain us without becoming obese, then the numbers are wrong. I mean, how could we have possibly made it as long as we have as a species if we are only now realizing that we can't eat enough good foods to be healthy???
Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by trukterious on Thursday October 25, 2018 @10:13AM
(#18301011)
>how could we have possibly made it as long as we have as a species if we are only now realizing that we can't eat enough good foods to be healthy?
Partly due to agricultural soil depletion of certain elements like magnesium, zinc, iodine.
Btw our prehistoric ancestors weren't especially healthy either:
Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by Matrixik on Thursday October 25, 2018 @11:00AM
(#18301394)
> Partly due to agricultural soil depletion of certain elements like magnesium, zinc, iodine.
Well, maybe yes or maybe no
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S088915751...
Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by apocolyps6 on Thursday October 25, 2018 @02:01PM
(#18303008)
It wasn't poor health killing people at 30. The leading cause of death at that age was hunting accidents. Besides that and the high infant mortality, people otherwise lived to ~70.
In addition to trukterious' point, which I agree with, I would echo that the idea that the RDA is just wrong is also a distinct possibility. Take a look at this: http://blogs.creighton.edu/heaney/2015/02/13/the-iom-miscalc... Ponder what it implies about the other RDA values. And look at the date. It wasn't that long ago.
I just pulled a fairly recent bottle of CostCo Vitamin D out here, and it's still using a value of 800IU as the RDA.
Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by TheCoelacanth on Thursday October 25, 2018 @02:42PM
(#18303402)
This seems like an example of the naturalistic fallacy.
Why assume that food with the optimally healthy composition of nutrients exists in nature? People can survive just fine without being maximally healthy.
Re:Green tea supplements ruined my liver
by JustSomeNobody on Saturday October 27, 2018 @11:36AM
(#18316189)
I didn't say "maximally healthy". It is, however, rather obvious that we were healthy and able to last this long and THUS the foods we had to consume gave us what we needed without having to take supplements.
There are some things that if you can't get them from a normal diet are certainly most easily obtained from supplements. Vitamin D, depending on your location, is certainly one. There's reasonable evidence that magnesium is another. IIRC, there's a couple of others where even eating a normal healthy diet won't really get you to where you ought to be. There's also plenty of vitamins where unless you eat a really crazy diet, or you've got some sort of absorption disorder (I'm in that camp so I've had to learn more about this than I really would have cared to), you're never going to be deficient, because you get plenty. Vitamin C, for instance, is effectively impossible to be deficient in. There's a lot of ongoing debate about the virtues of doses higher than "not deficient", but you'd have to go out of your way to get scurvy in the modern world.