News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by chongli on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:30AM (#18291140)
businesses don't seem to have a choice

Sure they do. There are plenty of smart, prudent retirement plans for companies to offer to their employees that don't involve crippling liabilities down the road. Defined contribution pensions, tax free retirement accounts, dollar-for-dollar matching (up to a limit) etc.

Defined benefit pensions were a bad idea born of a "I'll be retired before then so let's kick the can down the road" mentality.

Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by CydeWeys on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @08:31AM (#18291819)
Or even just direct contributions to retirement plans for all employees, no matching required. E.g. a company contributing $500 per month into the employee's 401k. My last company did something similar, but it was tied to salary and it was annual (prorated). I think a better case can be made for doing it monthly, so you don't need to bother with prorating, and also to do constant amounts for all employees rather than tie it to salary.

My current employer defaults employees to 10% and does dollar-for-dollar matching, but there's people who opt out because they want (possibly even need) all of their salary now, and thus they don't get any contributions in their plan. Yet these are precisely the people who would most need the contributions, because they're least likely to save up money in other vehicles!

Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by dantheman on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:29AM (#18292686)
I like the plans where the first 7% is granted, and the last 3% is a match -- it helps everyone, and encourages personal contributions.
Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by CydeWeys on Thursday October 25, 2018 @07:53AM (#18300194)
Definitely sounds better than most plans. Also what's been proven to be incredibly effective, and what many companies are doing now, is to make retirement contributions opt-out rather than opt-in. I forget the exact stats but it was something like 30% contribute to a plan if it's opt-in, but 80% do if it's opt-out. It's a huge difference.
Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by pjc50 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:06AM (#18292514)
I'm not sure a defined benefit pension is inherently worse than a defined benefit salary, but the real problem is tying it to the continued life of the company rather than a nice separate fund.
Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by Kalium on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:51AM (#18293472)
You're absolutely right!

A well-executed, professionally administered, and properly run defined benefit pension system is by far superior to every other option on offer. It offers predictable costs for the employer, predictable benefits for the employer, and all of this will continue without the company for as long as the pensioner lives.

In practice, there's been a lot of subtlety to this. It's very easy to make changes with low-visibility long-term negative impacts and high-visibility short-term positive impacts. Public-sector pensions in the US have famously assumed unrealistically high discount rates, among other things, because that turns into small contributions in the short term which employees and unions love.

Decades down the line, everyone gets screwed. But the people who made the bad decisions are well beyond accountability at that point. Since they know this, everyone involved is incentivized to think short-term. Never mind the issues that arise when life expectencies increase well beyond what pension fund planners knew to work with.

The popular workaround for this is a 401k or similar. This isn't ideal by any means. It takes away the defined benefits and the predictability and certainty for pensioners! The main upside is that it also removes the kind of misaligned incentives that can encourage poor decision-making and provides more assurance that something will be there later in life.

You're completely right. Pensions, when done properly, are amazing for everyone! The alternatives kinda suck by comparison. But they're much better than the answer many pension funds have provided.

(Salaries, being compensation for a defined term as well as defined amount, can be terminated, and are also compared to current value provided. And aren't assumed to generally last until employee death.)

Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by ghaff on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:28AM (#18292684)
It's not tied to the continued life of the company; for the most part, pension benefits are protected in a separate fund. (It's more complicated than that but I am by no means an expert.)

More to the point is that defined benefits, in addition to their other issues, are mostly oriented to long-term employment with a single company. If you move around every 2 or 3 years, you probably wouldn't get much if anything out of traditional defined benefit plans.

Traditional defined benefit pensions are nice in some ways for workers in that they're predictable. I'll even get a small one myself. But, like employer provided healthcare insurance, they're really not a good match for most purposes today.

Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by WorldMaker on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:14AM (#18293116)
Especially in a Wall Street environment hyper-focused on 3-6 month results over anything else. It's very hard for companies to plan long term if the only thing the market seems to care about is how they did last quarter of a year. It's an interesting Gordian knot that businesses seem to have tied themselves into where companies still have expectations to exist for multiple generations, but all the performance indicators used to analyze them are so strongly focused on the immediate short term.
Re:When Sears Flourished, So Did Workers. At Amazon, It’s Mo... by asr on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @12:44PM (#18294043)
Defined benefit plans have large drawbacks (risk to the firm, risk to retirees if the plan fails, etc.), but there is zero evidence they were born of a desire to kick the can down the road. They simply came first (at the time, as far as I'm aware, nobody had even thought of a defined contribution plan, and there would have been no tax reason to have one instead of just paying workers).[0]

Let's debate what works without pretending everyone who disagrees with us has terrible motives. Defined benefit plans provided huge benefits to many workers who have not managed the switch to defined contribution plans well.[1] That does not mean that pensions are sustainable, or even that they are a good idea, but their proponents are not just con-men.

[0] https://www.thebalance.com/the-history-of-the-pension-plan-2...

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2015/03/20/l-it-the-401k-is-a-failure.h...