Re:Bypass Paywalls – A Firefox extension to bypass paywalls ...
by zaarn on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:24AM
(#18291117)
Whether or not clearing cookies would count as bypassing is an interesting question, because Adblockers themselves are legal. The specific BILD case is about blocking and disabling a tool to detect adblockers, in which case it fully denies access to the article.
Ie, the anti-anti-adblock is actively interfering with the site's function on the client side.
Cookies and referer are handled on the server-side and outside the user's control.
I would question if the last sentences of 95a apply to setting a referer and clearing cookies. They are more closer to tampering with computer system (263a).
Re:Bypass Paywalls – A Firefox extension to bypass paywalls ...
by Tepix on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @06:43AM
(#18291210)
The first word of the law is "wirksame", which means "effective".
It's very easy to argue that this protection that is trivial to circumvent is not "wirksam".
Re:Bypass Paywalls – A Firefox extension to bypass paywalls ...
by darekkay on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @07:27AM
(#18291427)
Yes, that's why I've added the second link. Someone posted a tutorial on how to bypass the BILD Anti-Adblock. He argued that this is not an "effective" protection, but a court ruled an "Anti-Adblock" script as "effective".
Re:Bypass Paywalls – A Firefox extension to bypass paywalls ...
by yanonymous2 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @09:39AM
(#18292277)
It depends on the court. IIRC, that ruling came from the Landgericht Hamburg, which has become a bit of a running gag because of their copyright friendly rulings.
Re:Bypass Paywalls – A Firefox extension to bypass paywalls ...
by yanonymous2 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:13AM
(#18290830)
It still depends on whether the protection is considered effective.
In the case of this addon, the paywalls are often just overlays that you can also remove manually with a few clicks.
[0] https://dejure.org/gesetze/UrhG/95a.html
[1] https://www.wbs-law.de/it-recht/verbreitung-einer-anleitung-...