Re:UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
by kentm on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @11:36PM
(#18289519)
Its not specific to those examples though. Think of it like a thought experiment: a university literally can't host everyone so there's some criteria by which a guest needs to be judged.
In America, a lot of the spots were cancelled, IIRC, because protests necessitated increased security that couldn't be arranged or paid for. I'm not sure thats on the university.
Re:UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
by burfog on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:17AM
(#18290848)
Protests are an excuse. Protests are allowed and even encouraged by the university.
If the university actually wanted to stop protests, it would be trivial. Simply remove all support for protesters. (make this known in advance) This means: access cards stop working, transcripts are made unavailable, employees are fired, degrees are revoked, scholarships are terminated... some of this can be retroactive too.
When this has been done even in relatively limited form, protesters quickly stopped causing trouble. When the university gives tacit approval to the protesters, things quickly spiral out of control.
Re:UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
by kentm on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @11:09AM
(#18293072)
Protesting is a pretty fundamental right and societal value in America though. Cracking down on protests is, in my view, just as authoritarian as what the universities are accused of.
Re:UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
by furgooswft13 on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @05:42PM
(#18296685)
Rioting is not a fundamental right. An actual peaceful protest would not require prohibitively costly security arrangements.
Re:UK Universities: Is free speech under threat?
by kentm on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @10:59PM
(#18298290)
Whether something is a riot is often subjective and a lot of security arrangements are made for peaceful protests. After all a peaceful protest may turn into a riot. Or it may remain peaceful.
In fact most of the spots that have been called off were canceled well after they were scheduled and confirmed. If a university for whatever reason does not want to host the speaker at all, then just come right out and say so. Saying "Oh so sorry, we're all booked for the next 6 months!" is just a transparent excuse.