Re:Changing the world via Twitter? Yeah, you should get out ...
by _delirium on Monday October 25, 2010 @12:23AM
(#1828526)
Dixon's claim that he's made strong ties through Twitter is interesting. I haven't heard that before, even from people who use Twitter frequently (I use it quite frequently too). I definitely believe that people can form strong ties electronically, and I've done so on BBSs, IRC, forums, even mailing lists. I've never thought of Twitter as a place for that, though; its conversations are just too short and disjointed for me to feel much in the way of personal connection.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Changing the world via Twitter? Yeah, you should get out ...
by nkassis on Monday October 25, 2010 @12:42AM
(#1828579)
I've seen such things on HN at least. I've been contacted after posts I've made here and there are tons of people who received good help after asking for it on HN.
I don't think Dixon's is talking about the same thing as Gladwell. The examples that Gladwell cites are large movements not business or personal connections.
Re:Changing the world via Twitter? Yeah, you should get out ...
by jeffmiller on Monday October 25, 2010 @12:36AM
(#1828565)
I've formed some strong ties through Twitter, but as with Dixon's experience, they only begin on Twitter--they don't evolve there. Conversations quickly move to email, Skype and IRL.
Re:Changing the world via Twitter? Yeah, you should get out ...
by petercooper on Monday October 25, 2010 @02:04AM
(#1828752)
Ditto, though I'd say only about half of mine "move" elsewhere and the other half do evolve on Twitter alone. I follow about 900 people and frequently go through this list. At least half are people I now "know" through Twitter and identify with and know a little about. Many of them frequently help me out online, promote my projects, give me feedback, etc. This is very valuable to me.
But I'm a cave dweller who hardly goes out and I've been on Twitter since 2006 and use Twitter very proactively. I certainly sympathize with people who can't make it stick, though, because it almost takes being quite antisocial IRL to make putting the effort in worth it..