News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by rootusrootus on Monday October 22, 2018 @09:33PM (#18280112)
If GM doesn't make this data collection very explicitly opt-in (and backs it up with some kind of audit guarantee) then my '18 Camaro will be my first and last GM vehicle. Same with ads -- show me one, just one, and you lose me for good.

Other than that, I don't see why people are in here bragging about their awesome 15-20 year old cars. My brand new car has a manual transmission, a knob for the volume control, no built-in navigation, etc. The only real difference between this car and the one I owned in 2004 is that this is better in all ways. All.

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by setr on Monday October 22, 2018 @09:50PM (#18280173)
>Other than that, I don't see why people are in here bragging about their awesome 15-20 year old cars

Presumably because all those things you mentioned are difficult to find in new cars? I don’t think anyone is really of the opinion that newer cars have been degrading in mechanical quality; rather they’ve become much more unpleasant to use and own. Where you could trivially open up the car, theres specialized parts with manufacturer-specific tooling required (Even my car’s tire rim has a fucking key). Where the dashboard was mostly simple and operatable without looking, now you cant use any of it while in motion. And of course it’ll be slow, unreliable and somehow decide you need voice assistance and want to make a call.

And my own pet peeve: the incessant fucking beeping. Everything fucking beeps at you. I drove a prius recently: it beeps if you’re parked near the curb, beeps because you’re in reverse, beeps because of your seatbelt, beeps with the gps; stop by the gas station for a cacaphony: beeping and tvs and music just quiet enough that you can’t really make it out but youre aware its there. Expect the 2020 prius to beep while accelerating

Oh, and of course, now you can enjoy ads too, which’ll probably beep for your attention as well.

Obviously you can rip these things out, and obviously you can find cars without these things (especially if you’re paying the premium to customize), but these UX “improvements” are the norm, and you can reliably run from all of this horrible hell by turning back to 1996.

And if that car runs well, it’s probably much more pleasant to use than the same model in 2018. Mechanically worse, but far fewer “features” that enter the human areas.

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by hvidgaard on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:13AM (#18282363)
> Even my car’s tire rim has a fucking key

That is because some people think it's okay to take the wheels of the car when you park it.

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:36AM (#18282482)
Well, to be fair, it is lots easier to do when it is parked.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by SmellyGeekBoy on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @04:27AM (#18281699)
> I don't see why people are in here bragging about their awesome 15-20 year old cars.

Because they're having exactly the same driving experience as you while being tens of thousands of dollars better off?

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @05:14AM (#18281907)
>Because they're having exactly the same driving experience as you while being tens of thousands of dollars better off?

Don't forget about how nice it is to give zero fucks about your car.

"oh, gotta load a dirty lawnmower into the trunk, idgaf"

"oh, the bushes on this dirt road are overgrown and will scratch my paint, idgaf"

"gotta haul trash lumber to the dump, looks like a case of idgaf"

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by tk75x on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @01:02PM (#18294242)
I never understood this attitude. You should always "gaf" because taking care of your tools is a good thing to do, not treat them like crap and then complain when they break or don't function correctly.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by rootusrootus on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:09AM (#18283486)
Yeah, I own an old pickup for all of that. Having a new car also has upsides.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by rootusrootus on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @10:08AM (#18283481)
Well, to be fair, I doubt very much someone in a 2003 anything, much less a Toyota, is having the same driving experience I'm having in a brand new Camaro SS ;-)

Honestly, I've owned my share of old cars. Everything has a cost, sometimes it's money, sometimes it's hassle, etc. The marginal extra cost of a new vehicle is a rounding error financially at this point, so the biggest value is not having to worry about anything.

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by leetcrew on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @08:24AM (#18282722)
do you also smirk while you're having "exactly the same dining experience" at applebee's?
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by smnrchrds on Monday October 22, 2018 @09:59PM (#18280196)
If it proves a lucrative business model, you may not get a choice. Making "smart" TVs was lucrative, and now almost all TVs are smart. No matter whether you buy a Samsung,a Sony, or an LG. If advertising in cars becomes successful, no matter what brand you buy, expect it to come with ads.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by ericd on Monday October 22, 2018 @10:53PM (#18280394)
Sure you do. I've just stopped buying TVs. Projectors, at least, still seem mostly focused on displaying images.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by bscphil on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @08:23AM (#18282715)
Yep. I've got a 10 year old Plasma that still works and looks great. I will never own a car that advertises to me and sells my data. Hell, I'll never own a car that dings at me until I fasten a seatbelt if I can help it either.
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by slavak on Wednesday October 24, 2018 @03:26AM (#18290357)
> Hell, I'll never own a car that dings at me until I fasten a seatbelt if I can help it either.

Serious question: Why? I've never found it particularly helpful myself, but what's the big deal about a sound that reminds you to put on a critical safety device that you should already be using anyway? Do you really find yourself hearing those dings for long enough that it becomes a serious annoyance? If so, don't you think the ding isn't the actual problem there?

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by mrguyorama on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @08:58AM (#18282939)
I was still able to find a low model Vizio in about 47 inches that was dumb. It was a godsend
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by icebraining on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @06:20AM (#18282173)
PC monitors too; they make decent "TVs".
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by kennydude on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:29AM (#18282435)
This is why, for me, it's actually better to go for private label brands. They don't tend to bother
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by JustSomeNobody on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @07:39AM (#18282490)
Can't you just not tell it about your network and use it like a dumb TV?
[dead]
Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @02:51AM (#18281256)
They could iterate on image and sound quality, and keep charging for that. A larger screen, a thinner screen, less bevel, etc. Plenty to do to have an excuse for making a new model.

Also, the promise of market economy is that, under competitive pressure, in time product's price drops to near the actual costs of making it. Some products are simply done, and there should be a point at which the profit from sales is enough to just keep making it indefinitely, and the company could be free to pursue other products in other areas while still making the old one.

What wasn't the advertised part of the bargain is the ratchet effect - a company will add user-hostile feature, briefly get a better deal, then all other competitors will follow suit and suddenly the user-friendly product is no longer being made. We need to develop a way to prevent this.

Re:GM’s data mining is just the beginning of the in-car adve... by franciscrick1 on Tuesday October 23, 2018 @11:15AM (#18284054)
No, we don't. You might want to, but nobody else cares.