News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 21, 2018 @02:24PM (#18269355)
> Milk and cheese would be a good candidate for a basic income sort of scheme

Why milk? Vegetables make more sense.

Milk is not a necessary foodstuff. Creating labelling standards for high-quality milk and letting the market do its job would be the most-reasonable outcome.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by barrkel on Sunday October 21, 2018 @02:57PM (#18269513)
That's a universal argument for industrializing all food production. No food is a necessary foodstuff. It does not follow that all our food should be industrially produced.

(Free market food production will end up industrially produced, because that's how you minimize costs and maximize profits. I, for one, don't want to live in a country like that and will vote for laws that help prevent it happening.)

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 21, 2018 @05:56PM (#18270556)
> Free market food production will end up industrially produced, because that's how you minimize costs and maximize profits

Post-war Americans prioritised price. So the market made industrial food. (There was also the influence of World War II’s military-oriented factories pivoting to peacetime production.) The situation is not the same today.

There is demand for non-industrially produced food among those who can afford it. For those who can’t, I find it morally disturbing that those of us who can afford it want to tell them what they can and cannot buy. If a low-income person decides to spend their food voucher on industrially-produced cheese so they can use the surplus on fruits and vegetables (or pizzas), that’s their choice.

In any case, if the goal is less industrially-produced cheese, our subsidy regime accomplished that inefficiently.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by taborj on Monday October 22, 2018 @10:58AM (#18275142)
> If a low-income person decides to spend their food voucher on industrially-produced cheese so they can use the surplus on fruits and vegetables (or pizzas), that’s their choice.

That only works if there are no carry-on effects of their eating habits (i.e. subsidized health costs, etc). If we can reduce those carry-on costs by forcing the purchase of healthier options, then the system is more sustainable.

Add to that the fact that food subsidy programs are not intended to be a lifestyle -- they're supposed to be there to help people in times of need, a crutch to help them between jobs, not a solution to their joblessness. In other words, there should be some motivating factor to become self-sufficient.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by barrkel on Sunday October 21, 2018 @06:17PM (#18270675)
The trouble is that there's a ratchet effect which makes non-industrial food increasingly uncompetitive over time, and the only people who can afford decent goods and services are those who are wealthy. I wrote a long comment on this over a year ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13306700

I'm sorry for your feeling of disturbance. I can't help your sense of righteous indignation, but I don't believe free markets always deliver superior results to democracy.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by xyzzyz on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:00PM (#18269524)
Vegetables aren’t necessary either. Historically, humans (at least in Europe) consumed much more more milk than vegetables, deriving probably an order of magnitude more calories from dairy than from vegetables, because you could get more calories from an acre of cattle pasture than from an acre of grains fiels, and an order of magnitude more than from vegetables. Milk is also more nutritionally valuable, containing carbs, protein, and fat in very good proportion compared to vegetables. This is no surprise, since milk literally is produced by cows to be consumed by calves as their sole food.

I don’t think basic milk vouchers is a good idea, but basic veggies is even worse.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by Terretta on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:42PM (#18269739)
“Orders of magnitude” sprinkled generously make this sound more factual than it is.

Even though modern fruit and vegetable farming systems are highly industrialized, relying on vast monocultures, fertilizers, pesticides, and tillage practices that require heavy machinery and plenty of fuel, they still produce more calories per input than beef and pork.

Most views are 2x - 4x people fed per acre from plants versus meats, with milk and eggs splitting the middle.

That said, even our current ‘lacto ovo vegetarian’ compromise diet is likely not sustainable.

https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/78/3/660S/4690010

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by xyzzyz on Sunday October 21, 2018 @04:22PM (#18269985)
> they still produce more calories per input than beef and pork.

True, but irrelevant. I never said anything about meat. Since the advent of agriculture until modernity, most humans ate very little meat, this is definitely true.

> Most views are 2x - 4x people fed per acre from plants versus meats, with milk and eggs splitting the middle.

True, but irrelevant as well. Not only I never said anything about meat, but the discussion here is about milk vs. vegetables. Plants today are better yields in terms of calories per acre due to fertilizers being abundant, pesticides being available, and cultivars having been improved for better yields. However, it is irrelevant for the discussion at hand, because the plants that are better than milk are corn, soy, etc., not vegetables.

Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by Latteland on Sunday October 21, 2018 @06:19PM (#18270686)
maybe in parts of europe they got more from milk. i think veggies were more important everywhere else. Other people can't even eat milk!
Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by xyzzyz on Sunday October 21, 2018 @11:27PM (#18271988)
No, grains and tubers were more important everywhere where agriculture was a thing. Vegetables were relatively insignificant as source of calories.
Re:America Is Drowning in Milk Nobody Wants by honestlyidk on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#18269586)
you are completely steering the conversation away from what the original topic is. Its not like the post you replied to came out of no where with "I think milk and cheese is best". Most notably lactose intolerance which is not uncommon.