and secondly the threat of large-scale conflict with an adversary with a comparable military.
I just don’t see how increasing the efficiency of an already effective drone program protects against either of those threats. And as to the question of wanting people at google to work on it... I don’t think this sort of thing is what people join google to do. People interested in weapon systems probably go and work for known defense contractors and those companies do reasonably good work within the confines of their structure.
Without a deterrent, nothing. If we stigmatize building deterrents/weapons the other countries will step in and project their own values on the world because they’ll have to strength and technology to do so.
> Which do you trust more, a self-flying UAV with deadly cargo developed by Google or some random government contractor?
Neither. Why would you want google to develop uavs?
Don't create a weapon, if you don't want your enemies to have it too.
This is in no way intended as snark. It's a serious question. Where do we, as a society, put the dividing line between adequate, not enough, and too much military spending?
I certainly agree that many of America's recent military actions have likely not been a net contributor to world stability. But I also think that the commonly presented idea that if we just stopped, somehow there wouldn't be anyone left that wants to cause damage to the states is naive. The United States is one of the most developed countries in the world, and to be near the top is to have a target on your back, one way or another.
Is it not better to be clearly stronger, so as to be able to negotiate from a position of strength?
And again, to be clear, these are good-faith questions. What is it that we lose, as a society, by spending as we do on our military? What is it that we gain? There are solid points in both columns.
How does China's spend of ~228 billion compare in purchasing power to the US's 610? How does Russia's? What can we do to de-escalate the otherwise runaway cost of defense, while still maintaining a position of strength? I think Eisenhower's Military-Industrial Complex speech* from 1961 was exceptionally prescient, and we've done a poor job heeding the warnings. I also think that the general disdain I see on HN for most anything defense-related is an outlook only possible when one hasn't experienced living in actual conflict zones. We need to be able to talk about defense needs with clear, rational heads.
I'm thankful US Manhattan Project went on to successful completion, and not cancelled with above reasoning.
The series "The Man in the High Castle" shows what could've happened IF Hitler first got his nukes before US did. Most would agree that Hitler would've used it on London/NYC/DC with no qualms...
I think (not sure) Andrei Sakharov referred to Klaus Fuchs materials as a 'distraction'. Meaning it actually impeded their progress due to interference by Soviet political leaders. That's in line with a comment about the true nature of nuclear weapons 'secrets'. The secret isn't the design. The secrets are in the skills and technologies needed to manufacture a weapon. Which makes me think Klaus Fuchs and others were basically idiots.
Why do you think no other country could match USA R&D now or in foreseeable future?
And if that had happened, US (and rest of world) would've been really screwed. Manhattan Project used 1/7 of all electricity generated in US at the time. No way such gigantic project could've been conceived and completed in peace time in US. And definitely not fast enough if USSR had developed it first.
Furthermore, it's not really in the best interests of the general public to have already too-powerful tech companies running the largest and most omnipresent domestic surveillance systems becoming increasingly dependent on defense budgets. Those contracts give the government more leverage over the companies they fund and create more conflicts of interests.
If another country were to surpass the US military capabilities, more budget, more high-tech, more soldiers (let's say all of those), do you think that alone would mean a territorial threat to the US?
I mean, given that ever single country that isn't the US has lived with this exact situation for many decades, even if we assume it happens, why is that a problem? Even from a US point of view. When I say "US" I think we may also have to look at who exactly benefits, is it the majority of citizens?
I think there are a lot of potential very interesting questions that could be asked and answered. Just saying "this is bad" is not enough, not by itself, but mostly because I think you can start some really good discussions if you look at details. This includes questions about how and why one comes to the opinion that one chooses to express, not just that opinion itself. Seeing the path, the justification, is I think very valuable. Even more so when such fears lead to such extraordinary results as never before seen weapons and same for military spending.
Ukraine would have preferred holding on to Crimea, for one example.
(Plus the influence of Russian money in US politics; it's much cheaper to bribe the US not to fight back!)
We must protect our country. Let’s not be naive to the fact that we have enemies who want to destroy us, or overtake us in power and influence if we’re weak.
Personally I want the smartest people in the industry working on protecting our country and developing this tech.
Which do you trust more, a self-flying UAV with deadly cargo developed by Google or some random government contractor?