This is not a new concept, but it’s nice to see people realizing that they have a responsibility their inventions. People in tech make things more efficient, easier, cheaper. When tech skills are applied to weapons systems, those systems start to get terrifying —the machine does more of the work and it’s better, faster and cheaper. If you make a weapon that makes it easier and cheaper to kill it will be used to do just that. Once the invention leaves the creators hands the inventor gives up the power of choice and can not control if it is used for good or for evil (putting aside for the moment, the question of if it’s possible to kill for good). Is that who you are? Are you a maker of terrible weapons?
I can only answer for myself. I have the aptitude, but that’s not who I want to be. I’m not a pacifist, I have anger and fear and the urge to escalate in response to perceived injustice just like anyone else. But I make the conscious effort not to do violence, and not to create weapons. By doing that I decide that’s not who I am.
I don’t presume to answer for you, but I encourage everyone at least think it through and decide for themselves.
If the last war we had participated in was WWII and the cold war then who would object to advancing our weaponry in case we had to fight a terrible war again? Conversely, if we are routinely killing civilians in pointless decades long engagements in the Middle East, supporting both sides of civil wars in foreign lands, selling weapon systems to brutal monarchies, etc it's easier to see why people have doubts about participating.
The Vietnam War was immoral in many ways, but it was not a genocide. Throwing that term around willy-nilly cheapens it. Please don't.
A massacre is not genocide, neither is irresponsible environmental damage. It needs to have a specific intent and exist in a context that (is intended to) produce such massacres on a large scale.
e.g. German "reprisals" in France after partisan attacks were war crimes, but not genocide.
Edit: Oh, I forgot this is HN...
Antiwar sentiment goes up under Republican presidents
Like 1961-1969? Or 2009-2017?Probably they should just spin those divisions off into a different sister company under the Alphabet umbrella.
I think it’s quite reasonable to resist weaponizing machine learning. To say “I’m not comfortable making it cheaper and easier to kill large numbers of people at a distance”
If you were to do as you suggest and found or spin off a company to work on weapon systems, at least the people who joined would know what they were signing up for. I do hope you’d find it difficult to recruit, and I fear you’d not find it impossible.
I would like to think that thoughtful people would be able to see that building terrible weapons moves us closer to a world we shouldn’t be rushing to create.
Is it a general trend such as it happening in Engineering, and/or sciences or is it localised to just tech?
Perhaps the younger generation is more anti war?
Thoughts?