News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arcan versus Xorg – Approaching Feature Parity by newnewpdro on Sunday October 21, 2018 @05:51AM (#18267341)
Just having a thorough writeup describing how Arcan and Wayland differ in their overlapping areas would be useful in comparing how their architectures differ.

I understand Arcan is larger in scope than Wayland, but Arcan must have a protocol and architecture behind said protocol that can be meaningfully compared to Wayland's.

Re:Arcan versus Xorg – Approaching Feature Parity by crazyloglad on Sunday October 21, 2018 @09:44AM (#18267923)
The closest you'll get is the the "Clients and Privileges" section, and I much prefer to spend time on "what is" and "what will it become" than comparisons.

Part of the problem is that Xorg is much more well defined in that most can grok "what it is" so there is a point of reference to base an explanation from without 'too much' confusion, there's stuff to work on that isn't IRC logs or mailing list posts which is seriously 90% of Wayland right there.

Wayland is not a "protocol" in the traditional RFC/Jon Postel sense. Heck, even the spec PDF itself referred to itself as a Display Server. There's single X extensions with far more coherent descriptions than all of the Wayland Ecosystem. It's full of overloaded terms and technical WTFs!?. If anything, its the worst parts of Micosoft COM resurrected. An asynchronous Object Oriented IDL. Run for the hills.

Some say it'll fix security issues, it'll fix performance issues, it'll fix world peace -- with barely anyone answering or questioning "how", "why" or "why can't X?". When you counter-argue its feature anaemia it is "oh it's just a protocol, the compositor fixes that" and when you question the feature bulimia it is "oh that's compositor extensions, not the protocol".

Neither position is substantiated by its technical underpinnings, the protocol parts itself, nor the documentation, nor any of the the 'project goals'.

Re:Arcan versus Xorg – Approaching Feature Parity by kitotik on Monday October 22, 2018 @03:58AM (#18272920)
Upvoted for thoughtful, accurate points, but mostly for giving me the phrase ‘feature bulimia’.
Re:Arcan versus Xorg – Approaching Feature Parity by crazyloglad on Monday October 22, 2018 @09:19PM (#18280050)
It's your weapon now. Use it wisely.