News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The impact of gratitude on adolescent materialism and gen... by klodolph on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:52PM (#18264472)
Yes, children should absolutely be given enough space to develop on their own terms and explore their surroundings. However, to be blunt, the rest of the comment seems like it’s mostly feelings that you’ve developed based on your personal experiences (which are valid!) rather than a more measured assessment of our society.

My experience with Japanese children is limited, but when I worked in informal education we had a number of groups of high school students from Japan, and when I was in college there was a large group of exchange students from Japan. Some of my American friends went on to become full-time teachers in Japan… and some of the Japanese people I knew went on to become full-time teachers in America. My impression is that if you think that Japanese children are “given more freedoms to act independently” then this is probably a result of your cultural bias around what it means to be independent. The phrase that usually gets thrown around is “出る釘は打たれる”, which means “the nail that sticks out is hammered down.” There is generally a lot of structure in the lives of Japanese children. As for materialism—your mileage may vary. The Japanese people I’ve known haven’t been exceptionally different from Americans when it comes to broad aspects like materialism. Japan definitely has its share of brand-conscious consumers.

And this is a song and dance we’ve heard before. “If I only raise my child using principle X, then they’ll grow up to be great people.” There is no secret technique to raising better children, there’s just a million little things and a lifetime of effort.

There are no comments on this comment yet.