News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by manfredo on Saturday October 20, 2018 @01:36PM (#18264378)
Is a shrinking population actually bad in the long term? I'm taking on the order of centuries here. While it does introduce the dilemma of reducing spending on the elderly or increasibg taxes to care for the latter aging population, a shrinking population seems like it'd reduce environmental impact and global resource consumption in the long run.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by dragontamer on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:17PM (#18264610)
> While it does introduce the dilemma of reducing spending on the elderly

We live in a Democracy, and the elderly have the most free time and seem to be the biggest population right now (Baby Boomers). As such, the elderly are always going to be the most powerful voting block (doubly so now that Boomers, the biggest generation by population, is hitting retirement age).

Good luck "reducing spending on the elderly" in the coming years. Its politically infeasible on population dynamics alone.

When the "lack of children" issue starts to hit 40 years from now, Millennial are going to be retiring. Millennials are the 2nd largest population after the Boomers. So the same issue will hit us again in the long term.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by manfredo on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:11PM (#18265171)
The elderly may be a powerful voting block, but the percentage of people over 65 is still relatively low (~15% in the US). Even in countries with ageing populations, it's nowhere near the majority (Japan is 27%).

If taxes to pay for the elderly do become very onerous, 85-75% of the population is going to be against them politically. There are relatively fair measures to pay for their healthcare, like wealth taxes for people beyond retirement age and increasing estate taxes. Or a more politically feasible measure is to make social security means-tested.

By far the best solution would be to mandate people to pay into their own retirement funds - Singapore does this. But of course, that would have had to be put in place decades ago.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by imtringued on Sunday October 21, 2018 @06:54AM (#18267476)
Financing isn't the real the problem here. If 30% of the population works and 50% are retired then there are simply not enough workers to produce all the things you have saved up money for which will increase prices and inflate away your money. You can't "save" food and lots of other products the same way you can save money. It will spoil. This is why a home is actually a pretty good investment for retirement. If you buy it in your 40s then you will still have it in your 80s.

More output while at the same time reducing workers means more productivity is required and to increase the productivity per worker we need far more automation. Things like truck/taxi automation might cause a temporary mass unemployment problem for unskilled workers but at the same time also solve the worker shortage that will happen when the population starts aging massively.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday October 21, 2018 @07:03AM (#18267492)
Automation is occurring at a hectic rate in almost every sector. The last 15 years have seen more than the previous human history combined.

The idea that, the number of human being working is important at all, is rapidly becoming an obsolete issue.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by polskibus on Sunday October 21, 2018 @09:25AM (#18267860)
Automation yes, productivity is not necessarily improving, wages (in purchasing power) are mostly stagnant. There has been a lot of outsourcing going on in the last 15 years too, including moving a lot of factories to China, India. That can give a false premise that there has been a lot of automation going on, but in reality, globally there was little improvement.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday October 21, 2018 @09:36AM (#18267899)
No, outsourcing is included in the estimate. Outsourcing occurs when a process hasn't scaled up enough to be worth automating i.e. cheaper to hire overseas hands to do the process. When factories come back to America for instance, its because the process got large enough to warrant automation, which can be expensive. It bring nearly no jobs 'back'.

And productivity is funny. When folks move down the economic spectrum (from technical to office to labor etc) its called 'full employment' but almost by definition productivity of point-of-sale or labor is very low. Definitely there's no improvement for the individual.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by JoeAltmaier on Sunday October 21, 2018 @07:04AM (#18267496)
Its pretty easy in most elections for 15% of the population to be the majority. Since in the US at least, a 20% turnout is considered good.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by havetocharge on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:11PM (#18265179)
I dont really buy the argument that the elderly vote more solely because of the extra free time, or that the younger don't vote because of the lack of thereof. I suspect it's more to do with the different levels of understanding of the electorial process.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by adventured on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:11PM (#18264584)
The sole problem from population contraction, is replacement tax dollars for existing entitlement-type programs that are built on a ponzi scheme approach to ever larger inflows of tax revenue to support them over time.

Most of the developed world has the same problem on that front. The desperation by these countries when it comes to figuring out how to patch up the finances of those programs will increase by the year.

Robot (productivity) taxes will be one small answer. Another will be ever higher income taxes, also eventually including heavy wealth taxes (that comes last). Most of the developed or semi-developed world is starting to get hit on demographics at the same time. The weaker economic nations are being forced to respond first, as in Russia having to raise their pension ages so high it starts to cut people off at the life expectancy line (plunging Putin's popularity numbers in a rather startling fashion, which tells you how important the pension promises were). France is being forced to confront similar problems, with Macron trying to dress that up as market reforms. The US is temporarily avoiding it thanks to its ability to run absurdly high budget deficits for now.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by manfredo on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:00PM (#18265113)
I agree with the economic implications. Countries that experience an ageing population need to face the fact that they either have to raise taxes considerably, or reduce the care and benefits they extend to the elderly.

I also disagree heavily with the last paragraph. Creating disincentives for automation is the last thing a country needs when its workforce is shrinking. Automating jobs is a way of expanding the amount of labor available without actually needing more people in the work force. If anything, countries that are experiencing a population decline need to invest in more automation to maintain their economic output.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by amanaplanacanal on Monday October 22, 2018 @01:42AM (#18272440)
The US doesn't work that way. Taxes and spending have only the loosest correlation. As long as the US Dollar is the worlds reserve currency, it appears there doesn't have to be anything connecting the two.

Someday, though...

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by 8bitsrule on Saturday October 20, 2018 @11:21PM (#18266586)
"Ponzi scheme approach ..."

Like the stock market, then. And pension funds.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:31PM (#18265268)
> entitlement-type programs that are built on a ponzi scheme approach to ever larger inflows of tax revenue to support them over time.

Stop repeating propaganda please. Entitlement programs are just simple insurance programs. There is nothing ponzi about them.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by getpost on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:46PM (#18265372)
Huh? Social Security, for example, is definitely a Ponzi scheme in the sense benefits paid out far exceed amounts previously collected, saved, and invested. Numerous government programs rely on this logic, which only works if the population of working age people is expanding.

Social Security isn't a Ponzi scheme in the sense that there was fraudulent intent. Nevertheless, a lack of political will to finance current benefits does burden future generations. "Adjusting benefits downwards" won't sit too well with people who worked 30 or 40 years and expect to enjoy a certain standard of living.

Why Was Social Security Designed Like A Ponzi Scheme? https://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2015/08/13/why-was-...

Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? "Social Security has a funding gap equal to 0.7 percent of GDP over the next 75 years. We could wipe that gap out by lifting the payroll tax cap (right now, payroll taxes only apply to the first $107,000 of income) or by adjusting benefits downwards." https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/ezra-klein/post/is-soci...

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by addicted on Sunday October 21, 2018 @12:34AM (#18266755)
For one thing Social security’s structure is transparent, so no it’s not a Ponzi scheme at all in that a Ponzi scheme is by definition a subset of fraud and requires investors to be unaware of the fact the money coming to them is from new investors and not profits from investing in a product or portfolio of companies.

For another, it’s still not a Ponzi scheme. It makes no promises for returns, and simply requires working age people to set aside money for retired people. If the ratio changes, there is no requirement for the retired people to be paid the same money they were a year ago.

It’s not a Ponzi scheme in any fashion. It’s pretty much a direct, transparent transfer of wealth from the young to the elderly.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by jplayer01 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:46AM (#18267097)
You pretty much ignored everything he said and meant. Congratulations.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:17PM (#18269618)
Not really; a ponzi scheme has a very specific definition. A form of fraud in which belief in the success of a nonexistent enterprise is fostered by the payment of quick returns to the first investors from money invested by later investors.

Social Security isn't a ponzi scheme for a number of reasons, first it's not a security. Second there is no nonexistent enterprise. Instead it's structure is entirely that of an government mandated insurance program.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by chrisbrandow on Saturday October 20, 2018 @10:00PM (#18266418)
The other difference is that a true Ponzi scheme is fundamentally unsustainable, whereas social security is not. It may need adjustments, it’s not like you have exponentially growing divergence.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @10:15PM (#18266444)
If one looks here,

https://www.ssa.gov/oact/tr/2015/tr2015.pdf

> Total expenditures in 2014 were $859 billion. Total income was $884 billion, which consisted of $786 billion in non-interest income and $98 billion in interest earnings. Asset reserves held in special issue U.S. Treasury securities grew from $2,764 billion at the beginning of the year to $2,789 billion at the end of the year.

This is not in any shape or form a ponzi scheme.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toasterlovin on Saturday October 20, 2018 @11:25PM (#18266594)
You’re looking at inflows and outflows, which in the early stages of a ponzi scheme can also be similar. The way that social security in the US is a ponzi scheme is that the benefits paid out are not interest or earnings on the amounts paid in by the people receiving the benefits. They are paid for by new people paying in to the system. That is almost the definition of a Ponzi scheme.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @12:24AM (#18266726)
> You’re looking at inflows and outflows,

Which the generally accepted way of analyzing insurance programs is by looking at the inflow and outflows plus interest on reserves.

> which in the early stages of a ponzi scheme can also be similar

The Social Security Act passed in 1935.

> The way that social security in the US is a ponzi scheme is that the benefits paid out are not interest or earnings on the amounts paid in by the people receiving the benefits. They are paid for by new people paying in to the system. That is almost the definition of a Ponzi scheme. That is almost the definition of a Ponzi scheme.

No that is the exact definition of an insurance program. Insurance programs are not investments they are about spreading risk. Which the Social Security Program in the US does a perfectly fine job of.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toasterlovin on Sunday October 21, 2018 @02:49AM (#18267002)
No, insurance is categorically different. It protects you against a loss of some kind, and only provides that protection while you are paying for it. As such, only a difference between the predicted and actual risk covered by the insurance policy can cause an insurance program to become insolvent. A change in the number of people buying insurance from year to year will have no effect on the solvency of the insurance program, as long as the actuaries predict the risk covered by the insurance correctly.

Social security is a pension. It guarantees a future stream of income in return for payments now. It is subject to the same actuarial risk as insurance (so, predicted payout period ends up being longer than expected, or returns on payments are lower than expected), but it is subject to an additional risk if it is unfunded (which Social Security is). That risk being that inflows become insufficient in the future to cover the outflows promised 40 years prior.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by mturmon on Sunday October 21, 2018 @01:14PM (#18268945)
There is a difference between term life insurance, which you’re referring to, and universal life insurance. Social Security is indeed similar to universal life insurance.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toasterlovin on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:27AM (#18272183)
Thank you for providing an actual example of insurance that works this way. I actually looked at the insurance article on wikipedia and it was describing what I was describing (unless I missed something about universal life insurance). And I actually had auto, property, and health insurance in mind more than life insurance.

That being said, the important distinction still stands: Social Security is unfunded, which makes it subject to a kind of risk that funded insurance programs are not exposed to.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @03:20PM (#18269628)
> No, insurance is categorically different.

No.

> It protects you against a loss of some kind,

Social security protects you against outliving your savings when you can no longer work.

> and only provides that protection while you are paying for it.

This is an argument from ignorance. And it's incorrect.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toasterlovin on Monday October 22, 2018 @12:28AM (#18272189)
You’re still not addressing the main reason that comparing social security to a Ponzi scheme makes sense: being unfunded means that people will get royally fucked if the number of people paying in starts shrinking.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Monday October 22, 2018 @04:07AM (#18272954)
Social security is funded via FICA which is mandated by the Federal government. You aren't going to get a more sure source of funding than that.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @06:01PM (#18265739)
> Social Security, for example, is definitely a Ponzi scheme

Social Security is an insurance program. That you don't understand how insurance programs work is your problem.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by TheCoelacanth on Saturday October 20, 2018 @05:59PM (#18265730)
It's not just entitlement programs, retirement in general is a Ponzi scheme.

The only way that anyone can retire is to rely on the productivity of people who are still working. Saving up money for retirement does not avoid this. Your saved up money just lets you buy someone else's future productivity, you can't actually live on it.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by imtringued on Sunday October 21, 2018 @07:06AM (#18267500)
Exactly! Imagine a future in which 100% of the population is in retirement. Who is going to run the farms that produce the food? The only way to get food is by stockpiling it during your working age and somehow preserving it for decades until you have reached your retirement age.

This clearly isn't viable so instead we have kids that take care of us when we become old.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by dgudkov on Saturday October 20, 2018 @09:12PM (#18266310)
>Is a shrinking population actually bad in the long term?

Technically speaking, for all known biological species, the size of population is the primary indicator of health and well-being. Shrinking population indicates either inability to adapt, or some kind of malaise.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by api on Saturday October 20, 2018 @05:52PM (#18265691)
It's not necessarily a bad thing, but it completely breaks all of modern finance.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by pauljurczak on Sunday October 21, 2018 @05:26AM (#18267283)
Great!
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toomuchtodo on Sunday October 21, 2018 @06:34AM (#18267422)
Don’t get too excited about tearing engines off an in flight aircraft unless you have an acceptable substitute ready.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:01PM (#18264526)
While this may be true, it's not that much of an exaggeration to say that capitalism is a Ponzi scheme. At the very least our current economic system is dependent on continuous growth, including population growth, and when that ends there will be a world of hurt.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by manfredo on Saturday October 20, 2018 @02:07PM (#18264557)
> and when that ends there will be a world of hurt.

First world countries' with shrinking populations aren't falling apart. Sure places like Japan, Italy, and Spain have economic troubles associated with a growing retirement population, and shrinking workforce. But they're still pretty good places to live in.

While global growth would decline, I'm dubious of the claim that per-capita wealth would go down. With the same pool of resources spread across fewer people, the opposite seems likely. The labor force would reduce in size, too, so manufactured goods and services may not see their prices go down. But things that are zero-sum like natural resources, real-estate, etc. should drop in cost as fewer people are competing for them.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Saturday October 20, 2018 @04:26PM (#18265240)
I take the argument that from an economists view point negative population growth is a very bad thing indeed. But from an individuals point of view actually not. Because the economist only cares about total 'GDP' and is absolutely uninterested in quality of life. Because quality of life can't be monetized.

From an individuals point of view lower population means fix resources are spread less thinly. There is less competition for jobs so you can command a large share of the pie.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by bodas on Saturday October 20, 2018 @07:08PM (#18265960)
There may be less competition for jobs but when you're elderly there's more competition for people to take care of you.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by toasterlovin on Saturday October 20, 2018 @11:21PM (#18266585)
Old people have resources, though, so NBD. Reasonable societal arrangements should favor new families at the expense of old folks.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by Gibbon1 on Sunday October 21, 2018 @05:51AM (#18267339)
Old people often don't use that many resources either at least while they are in good health. Most of the costs are associated with the last year or two of life. SO that expense is already committed to when they born.
Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by rz2k on Sunday October 21, 2018 @11:02AM (#18268301)
A new equilibrium with a smaller population, after the problem of an old population had passed, would still imply less room for specialization, and therefore less per capita productivity, and ultimately lower quality of life.

Instead of more natural resources available per person, a less productive economy eventually provides for fewer resources in terms of goods, services and capital like installed infrastructure per person that are necessary to thrive.

Re:As U.S. fertility rates collapse, finger-pointing and bla... by lkrubner on Sunday October 21, 2018 @12:18PM (#18268713)
That's a moot point for as long as we still have 3.5 billion people engaged in subsistence level farming. All of them need to be brought into the modern economy, and taught a specialty. In other words, if 50% of the human race is still wasting its time with farming practices that have barely changed since the Neolithic, then there are still a lot of ways to grow the economy, even if the population is falling.