News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cleveland.com’s ‘right to be forgotten’ removes names fro... by Retric on Friday October 19, 2018 @01:43PM (#18258475)
Why let people out of prison? What's the point of temporary incarceration without any form of rehabilitation?

Presumably, if society is willing to let people return it must gain from their return. That cost benefit trade-off is the exact same one that occurs with your website example.

Re:Cleveland.com’s ‘right to be forgotten’ removes names fro... by cortesoft on Friday October 19, 2018 @02:26PM (#18258832)
You can't force 'society' to change its opinion of former criminals via acts of law. The law can only govern a very limited scope of behavior, not peoples opinions or feelings.

I agree our society does not treat ex-convicts well. But changing that requires a cultural shift, not a legal one. We should work on getting people to humanize ex-convicts, not legally trying to make them forget they are ex-convicts.

Re:Cleveland.com’s ‘right to be forgotten’ removes names fro... by sk5t on Friday October 19, 2018 @02:09PM (#18258700)
Rehabilitation is certainly in society's interests--I don't imagine there's any argument to be made against it.

However, the 1st amendment to the US Constitution puts strong limitations on the ability of the government to prevent or censor expression. How can the worthy goal of improving convicts' rehabilitation--albeit via suppressing news and opinion--possibly square with free speech?

Re:Cleveland.com’s ‘right to be forgotten’ removes names fro... by tedunangst on Friday October 19, 2018 @02:12PM (#18258715)
I wonder if this rule should apply to corporations. Should HN autokill comments calling Microsoft a convicted monopolist? They paid their fine, so all is good, right?

Or what about bad yelp reviews? If you exterminate the cockroaches, can you delete all the bad reviews?