Re:Canadian scientists protest gag order, go straight to pub...
by _delirium on Sunday October 24, 2010 @02:57AM
(#1825460)
It seems there's some tension playing out between whether these are the government's scientists who do research and report back to the government; or the public's scientists, paid by the government, but doing research and reporting it directly to the public.
In the first model, the government asks its scientists to research something, they come back with an internal whitepaper, and it decides when, how, and if to report that publicly, controlling the external message. Similar to how staff scientists at a company operate. In the second model, publishing and media-interview decisions are made at a fairly low level, sometimes with individual scientists directly publishing results without managerial review. Management may still run strategic PR campaigns highlighting certain things, but they're usually in addition to, rather than instead of, the original release of findings.
NASA responded to a similar controversy in 2006 by explicitly saying that NASA scientists can talk to the media about scientific research or their personal opinions without prior approval, as long as they're disseminating unclassified information and are clear that they're speaking in a personal capacity (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03...).
In the first model, the government asks its scientists to research something, they come back with an internal whitepaper, and it decides when, how, and if to report that publicly, controlling the external message. Similar to how staff scientists at a company operate. In the second model, publishing and media-interview decisions are made at a fairly low level, sometimes with individual scientists directly publishing results without managerial review. Management may still run strategic PR campaigns highlighting certain things, but they're usually in addition to, rather than instead of, the original release of findings.
NASA responded to a similar controversy in 2006 by explicitly saying that NASA scientists can talk to the media about scientific research or their personal opinions without prior approval, as long as they're disseminating unclassified information and are clear that they're speaking in a personal capacity (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03...).