News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help stop the spread of NIBS (Native is Better Syndrome) by acqq on Saturday October 23, 2010 @09:13PM (#1824867)
But native IS better, at least considering:

- faster code (that allows you to implement something more complex or more demanding)

- better interfaces (allows you to have an app that is really "in the spirit" of the platform which does matter).

- significantly easier way for a customer to pay for the app.

Author's arguments for non-native and how I see them:

1) He can have the URL to different settings of the "web app." -- just please explain that to users that they need that and earn the money.

2) "already, and increasingly into the future, you’ll be able to develop with a single code base, and deploy to (ultimately) any platform" -- oh right, and everybody will use exactly the hardware you have, with the same resolution, same input mechanisms and the same controls.

3) "Distribution control: With 'native' apps, you must go through a third party, who owns the platform" -- this is the only significant argument, IMHO.

The third argument is really an important one. In some cases it can be a deciding one. But it alone can't be used as a proof that native apps aren't better in enough real cases, and that there's "a syndrome."

There are no comments on this comment yet.