News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by dbingham on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:05AM (#18247953)
Well, that's fun. The linked blog post doesn't seem to exist. I can find no mention of this new release on Jira's blog anywhere. Plus, there's no release date for these features (which seem like desperately needed improvements) anywhere. Matches my experience with Jira so far.

Our PM team recently requested we move from Waffle to Jira, since Waffle has no backlog management and Github's is lacking from a PM point of view. As a developer, this is a giant leap backwards.

Jira is a terrible mess of throw spaghetti at the wall and hope it works out. A jumble of all the features you could possibly want, half-assed and thrown together with terrible UX. The data model is non-sensical (everything is shared between projects - if you create a status, a field, an issue type, it becomes the one true object shared by everyone), making the damned thing impossible to configure.

The way kanban boards currently work is that they don't scroll. They adjust their horizontal scaling to shove all the columns on to the screen. Dragging cards between them frequently fails, because when you are dragging, you can end up scrolling and that will knock Jira's awareness of the card's position out of whack. When you drag the card, it greys out the board and highlights the columns you can drop it in in green - which is how I know that Jira's position tracking gets out of whack. After I've dragged to cause an accidental scroll, the column I'm hovering over will fail to highlight, but the one two columns over will highlight.

The whole thing needs to refresh every time you make a change. Or when someone else makes a change, instead of just showing the change you get a little box saying "please refresh me". To see your PRs attached to a card, you have to click into the card, then click into the PR list. It doesn't list which repo each PR belongs to anywhere, so you have to put that in the title yourself if you want to be able to see it from Jira. You can't see review status or comment status from Jira, so you have to click straight through to the PR if you want to see how the conversation has moved.

And yeah, right now, you have to configure your workflow independently of the columns and then attach the the statuses to the columns. Figuring that out took a solid day of clicking around in the nightmarish admin sections. Now that I'm using it and not trying to configure it, it's annoying, it's definitely slowing me down over waffle, but it's... manageable. But god I miss waffle.

These changes, if they actually exist look like they would salve some of these pains... at least a little.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by rbanffy on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:55AM (#18248310)
> Well, that's fun. The linked blog post doesn't seem to exist. I can find no mention of this new release on Jira's blog anywhere. Plus, there's no release date for these features (which seem like desperately needed improvements) anywhere. Matches my experience with Jira so far.

It feels like Venturebeat messed up a news embargo. My bet is that it'll be announced shortly.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by seanjregan on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:39AM (#18248662)
:)
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by Karunamon on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:21AM (#18248058)
> The data model is non-sensical (everything is shared between projects - if you create a status, a field, an issue type, it becomes the one true object shared by everyone)

No, that's not the case. If you create any of those new objects, you have to explicitly add it to what you want it to be associated with. New fields have to be added to screens and schemes, new issue types associated with issue type schemes and then to projects, and so forth. None of this happens automatically from the admin side.

If you want to share stuff across projects, you can, but it is in no way a requirement.

> As a developer, this is a giant leap backwards.

The only Jiras I've ever seen suck that hard is when the end users are treated as hostile rather than stakeholders in the deployment. It can be as easy to use or as complicated to use as the people writing your workflows and screens.

That applies to the UI as well. The basic UI, OOTB, is fairly easy to understand. Once you have management dictating 30 different required fields along 50 different projects, each with their own issue types and workflows... yeah, it can get hairy.

> To see your PRs attached to a card, you have to click into the card, then click into the PR list.

This is going to be a bit "you're holding it wrong", but why would you expect to see PRs at the card level rather than the detail view? The agile board is meant to show who and what, not how. PRs would be meaningless noise to the average user of an agile board, not to mention taking up the limited space available on a single card.

Those issues aside, you'll never hear me accuse Jira of being easy to administer. It's a tool that tries to be all things to all people, meaning it will take a non-trivial amount of time to get your head around and have some rough edges.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by dbingham on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:55AM (#18248313)
Have you ever used waffle or something like it? Waffle attaches PRs as little rows underneath the primary card. On the PR row you have a one click link to pop open the PR in a new tab, an indicator of each review on the PR (and its status - whether there are new comments etc), an indicator of the build status and the ability to assign someone to the individual PR as opposed to the card as a whole.

As a developer lead, these features are extraordinarily useful. I can see the exact state of the card, and all its attached PRs across multiple repos, at a glance. I can jump into any of the PRs to contribute comments, update a review, make a review. I can make use of the PR assignment to assign different people to different parts of the overarching card (assign a different dev to the infrastructure PR, than for the front end PR, for instance) or to assign people to do the review while leaving the executing dev on the primary card.

It's a well designed UX that's trying to be exactly one thing: a highly functioning kanban board tightly integrated with Github. And it shows what good UX design can accomplish.

It's not perfect, but it's miles better than Jira and I'm feeling its lack having to move from Waffle to Jira.

To respond to the first point, I'm reacting to the fact that everything exists in common and must be associated rather than simply created. If someone's created a "Story Points" field already on another project, that's the one true "Story Points" field. If I want a different one for my project, I have to name it something else. And if other people have created a bunch of fields, you can quickly find yourself swimming in a mess.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by seanjregan on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:43PM (#18251941)
With this new release of Jira everything is no longer "common", This means we've moved from a more global permissions policy to a more local on. "Project Based" if you will. This means that within a "project" you have more flexibility to design the way you want to work at a project level (boards, issues etc. than you ever did in the past.
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by rmag on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:13AM (#18248458)
Jira PM here. Sorry to hear about your experience and thanks for your feedback. We know it can be really difficult to use Jira Software Cloud, which is why we've reimagined how it works. I assure you the team listens, so please take another look and give the 'next-gen' projects a try.

> Plus, there's no release date for these features (which seem like desperately needed improvements) anywhere. We're fixing the blog post link, it'll be up very soon. All the features in the video / article is live. If you haven't yet, please watch here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHLzrYYlgAU attached to the article, is a good representation of what we have now. Create a new 'next-gen' project within your Jira Cloud instance to try it out.

> A jumble of all the features you could possibly want, half-assed and thrown together with terrible UX.

For 'next-gen' projects, features (like sprints, backlogs, etc) can now be turned on and off when it's appropriate for your team. We regularly listen to feedback and have shipped numerous updates to address some design flaws and bugs for features available.

> The data model is non-sensical (everything is shared between projects - if you create a status, a field, an issue type, it becomes the one true object shared by everyone), making the damned thing impossible to configure.

For 'next-gen' projects, the data model has been reimagined, configuration options are currently scoped to the project. On top of that, configuration is drag-and-drop, much clearer and intuitive. As we build more features and configuration options, we run interviews, perform usability tests, look at in-product feedback, amongst other channels, to make sure that we're not adding unnecessary layers of complexity. If we are, we change and iterate.

In the future we'll be introducing customisable project templates, which allow you to save and share an entire project configuration. Instead of sharing data objects, your teams can reuse or fork templates, making for a better UX. As you can imagine, Jira has many configuration options so we're carefully thinking about how to approach this without the difficulty curve of the classic data model.

> The way kanban boards currently work is that they don't scroll. They adjust their horizontal scaling to shove all the columns on to the screen.

For 'next-gen' projects, we've fixed this. The scrolling is responsive, we've changed how horizontal scaling works and the card updates are near realtime. Our team is working on more performance improvements so expect a snappier experience over time.

> The whole thing needs to refresh every time you make a change.

We've updated the tech stack, this should happen less now with the 'next-gen' projects.

> You can't see review status or comment status from Jira, so you have to click straight through to the PR if you want to see how the conversation has moved.

You can see updates about the branch, commits and PR: https://confluence.atlassian.com/jirasoftwarecloud/files/777...

For commenting on PRs, I think that's a fair call - thanks for this feedback. I'll relay this to the team.

> And yeah, right now, you have to configure your workflow independently of the columns and then attach the the statuses to the columns.

In 'next-gen' projects, we've fixed this. The default behaviour is that creating columns on the board updates the workflows. Hence you don't have to run into multiple steps of configuring your workflow, make statuses and add columns. Right now what we have is simple and we plan to build more customisability on the workflow editor but we will be very careful to make sure we don't run into usability problems like what you just mentioned.

Thanks again for the time in leaving valuable feedback for our team.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by dbingham on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:54AM (#18248797)
Well, I just found the NextGen projects and have been playing around with them. This looks like a massive improvement. Fixes most of my pain points. I'm still going to miss Waffle's tight integration with Github -- being able to see the PRs under the cards along with their review and build status at a glance was wonderful.

But this makes Jira much less of an "Oh god, do I have to open that?" and much more of a tool I can actually make use of. Before I was in a state grudging accepting (because our PMs clearly needed it) while dreading the change. Now I can reach of state of peaceful acceptance. I'll make use of the feedback link as I find things. Thanks for the hard work I'm sure the team put in to make this real!

Edit to add: After playing with it more, I would just ask that you, at the least, make that PR icon that shows on the card clickable to jump straight to the PR. Or find someway to expose a list of PRs and their state on the card itself.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by patrickt010 on Thursday October 18, 2018 @08:03PM (#18253382)
Designer on Jira, thanks for the feedback! I've shared this with the team, and this is something that we are considering. Keep the feedback coming!
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by seanjregan on Thursday October 18, 2018 @04:40PM (#18251920)
Did you check out the new integration with GitHub? https://techcrunch.com/2018/10/04/github-gets-a-new-and-impr...
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by OliverLassen on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:33AM (#18248606)
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by liveoneggs on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:16AM (#18248019)
I thought dragging a "card" with the mouse was some kind of web-demo joke before seeing people expected to actually perform the action multiple times per day.
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by mercer on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:28AM (#18248101)
I use Trello quite a bit for various clients and I love the visual/tactile nature of dragging cards. I wouldn't use it for a massive number of support tickets or the like, but it's great for the slightly higher-level stuff (ongoing feature work, etc.).
Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by addicted on Thursday October 18, 2018 @09:39AM (#18248192)
Agreed. Trello is great for high level items, or for breaking down a specific project. It seems much more cumbersome for things in the middle where you are trying to focus on many different projects at a deeper level.

My wishlist for Trello would be a parallel spreadsheet like UI that would make it easy to view and modify details of a large number of different cards in 1 go.

Re:Atlassian debuts new Jira Software Cloud with timeline vi... by s1mon on Thursday October 18, 2018 @10:05AM (#18248392)
While I like the UX of Trello in general more, Smartsheet has a spreadsheet view and more.