News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by rayiner on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:12PM (#18232261)
Antitrust theory says that a company should not be able to use a product where it has a monopoly to get people to use another product where it lacks a monopoly. If we assume that Google has a monopoly on smart phone platforms with Android/the Google Play Store, (I take no position on whether that's true) it should not be able to leverage that monopoly to get people to use Maps and YouTube, where it has no monopoly.

That doesn't mean that Google has to "work for free." Nothing prevents them from simply charging money for Android and the Play Store. But Google doesn't want to be Symbian, getting a $10-15 one-time license free per phone. Instead, it wants to use Android/GPE as a vehicle for getting people to use apps like YouTube, which generate recurring revenue. That's a great business strategy, but if you're too successful with it, you run into antitrust concerns. (Google's should've probably taken a page from Intel/Microsoft and paid off Symbian or Blackberry to keep working on an Android competitor.)

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @11:59PM (#18236028)
> Nothing prevents them from simply charging money for Android and the Play Store.

So what happens when they do just that, but the price for Android + Play Store sans Google Apps is ~$150, i.e. the same price as Microsoft Windows?

It's completely fair to ask that they offer an a la carte version for full price, but then almost everyone would choose the free/discounted version that bundles the services.

It's also fair to ask that the user be able to uninstall them, but again most of them won't.

What the hardware vendors are really after is the ability to sell the default position to someone else. The profit from which disappears with the discount Google was giving them for exactly that.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by apexalpha on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @06:47AM (#18237815)
>So what happens when they do just that, but the price for Android + Play Store sans Google Apps is ~$150, i.e. the same price as Microsoft Windows?

In that case other companies, say, Micrsoft could then start to offer a $100 Android version containing Edge, Bing Maps, Hotmail as services.

Exactly what this anti-trust measure try to accomplish. Now, this is not possible since Google forces you to install Chrome if you want Play Store. Which basically leverages it's monopoly on mobile OS to get more market share in the browser game.

Re:Google to Charge Phone Makers for Android Apps in Europe by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday October 17, 2018 @01:50PM (#18241568)
> In that case other companies, say, Micrsoft could then start to offer a $100 Android version containing Edge, Bing Maps, Hotmail as services.

Just like Microsoft offers a $100 iOS the same way, right? All you're asking for is for Google to stop developing Android for free. Then Google's version becomes macOS to the legacy Android's FreeBSD, or WINE trying to keep up with every change to Windows.

It would make it harder to develop an alternative to Google Play than it currently is because then you would also have to produce an alternative to Android.

And it does nothing to solve the actual problem, which is that app stores have network effects, so users won't use one with no apps and developers won't use one with no users. Even ignoring Android, suppose the value of Google Play to the OEM is $50 and the value of being default to the highest bidder (e.g. Microsoft) is $20. Then the OEMs have been getting a discount of $30 to get both for net of zero.

Now suppose you price them separately and Google offers Google Play for $35 and pays $35 to be the default. The result is exactly the same. Google Play is worth $50 to the OEM over alternatives, costs $35, so they net $15 by choosing it. Google Apps pay $35 when the alternative pays $20, so they net $15 by choosing it. No change in behavior at all.

If you want to actually fix it you need to break the network effect, e.g. separate the Google Play service from the Google Play app, so that anyone can build a store app that can install apps from multiple stores (even if OEMs still have to pay for access to Google Play). Then explicitly allow app developers to pass the store fee onto customers using that store through differential pricing between stores, so that the same apps from stores with lower fees actually have lower prices. That's how you get more stores, which is how you break Google's leverage with the Play Store.