Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by jay-anderson on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:40PM
(#18232006)
The code for windows has been leaked and people could get the source. Sometimes companies have agreements for viewing the source of software they produce. These are two examples where the source code is visible, but this alone does not make them open source. There must be other attributes beyond just being able to see the source code.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by dtech on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:42PM
(#18232015)
You're not using a useful definition.
If I give you some source code, with the license that you cannot run the software, modify the code or copy or use the code in any way, it follows your definition and is still useless.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by the_af on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:09PM
(#18232234)
> For me it's actually the definition of open source, having the sources in the open.
But that's not actually the most commonly accepted definition of open source. It means something else, as widely understood by the software community.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by plopz on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:08PM
(#18232796)
My definition is the same as his. Is there a poll or survey somewhere that determined what the commonly accepted definition was?
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by gnud on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:46PM
(#18233103)
Well, there's this thing called the OSI [1], and they have this definition that's been around for a while. From their website:
> The “open source” label was created at a strategy session held on February 3rd, 1998 in Palo Alto, California. That same month, the OSI was founded.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by the_af on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @05:03PM
(#18233246)
Well, besides OSI's definition -- which I understand is being questioned in this comments section, so I suppose mentioning it is begging the question -- most of the bibliography and articles out there use "open source" in the sense I mentioned.
Microsoft was also aware of the accepted meaning, which is why they introduced their "Shared Source Initiative" back in the old days (note how deviously careful they were about the naming).
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license
by plopz on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @05:44PM
(#18233570)
Honestly, this comment section is the first time I've heard about the OSI, I guess whenever I read articles that use "open source" I've assumed a definition that may not be technically correct. I would hazard a guess that my definition is probably more widely held but that could just be my personal bias.
For me it's actually the definition of open source, having the sources in the open. After you can have more or less restrictive licenses.