News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by JaimeThompson on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:14PM (#18231143)
I wasn't aware that the OSI was the only one who could declare something to be "OPEN SOURCE". Is there a certification fee to have my license / code blessed with the designation?
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by vmbrasseur on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:16PM (#18231163)
There's no fee, and no need to submit any code.

The entire approval process is documented on our website: https://opensource.org/approval

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by JaimeThompson on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:21PM (#18231223)
I don't see anything on that page with gives you, the OSI, the legal right to declare things as being opensource or not. You categorically stated it wasn't opensource. Had you stated that in your opinion it wasn't opensource it would be different.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:01PM (#18231591)
>>I don't see anything on that page with gives you, the OSI, the legal right to declare things as being opensource or not.

Sorry, who said anything about a "legal" right?

Maybe you're reading too much into the OP's comment.

Mongo submitted an application at OSI, and OSI is saying that currently, they don't consider Mongo open-source, based on their own definition.

Perhaps you're just confused?

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by vmbrasseur on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @01:29PM (#18231303)
Please see this comment for more information: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18231270
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by ubernostrum on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @08:46PM (#18234597)
I don't see anything that gives you, JaimeThompson, the legal right to declare what others can and can't say.
[dead]
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by JaimeThompson on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @05:24PM (#18233416)
Nope. I just dislike it when someone tries to claim control over a simple English words. They don't have a trademark on open source so they don't get the right to go around saying what is / isn't open source.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by sascha_sl on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @06:20PM (#18233794)
They made up the term and their definition is what most people associate with "open source". This is not a legal right, it's just "let's not redefine words because we don't like their common meaning".
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by shakna on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @09:41PM (#18235016)
> It wasn't defined at some party or demo-conf.

Actually, that's exactly where it was defined.

> I brainstormed this with some Silicon Valley fans of Linux (including Larry Augustin of the Linux International board of directors) the day after my meeting with Netscape (Feb 5th). We kicked around and discarded several alternatives, and we came up with a replacement label we all liked: "open source". [0]

Also note, that the OSI didn't exist when they came up with this new label.

[0] http://www.catb.org/~esr/open-source.html

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by cesarb on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:18PM (#18231766)
> Their OSD is what defines open source. You didn't define it. It wasn't defined at some party or demo-conf. It was defined by the OSI - they defined Open Source Software.

Isn't the OSD basically the DFSG? Therefore one could argue that it was actually defined by Debian, not the OSI.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by tannhaeuser on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @04:19PM (#18232875)
You may be talking past another. I guess what GP was asking is whether OSI has a trademark, copyright, or something else for the term "open source"? The term "open source" has been generically used for much longer than OSI's existence.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by icebraining on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:26PM (#18234187)
The term "open source" has been generically used for much longer than OSI's existence.

I've seen this claim before, but could never find any evidence of it actually being applied to software before OSI came around.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by nemo44x on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:25PM (#18231855)
It was literally defined at a party. Or a strategy session to be precise.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:47PM (#18232050)
Big difference between a "party" and a strategy session. So it wasn't literally defined at a party. And, even if it were, I guess it doesn't matter. The OSI owns the OSD which is what defines what Open Source is.
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by kemitchell on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @07:11PM (#18234085)
The process I underwent for The License Zero Reciprocal Public License last year, and the process described to me by participants affiliated with OSI during those discussions, did not match the process described on the page you linked at the time, especially its "What Will Happen" section. At least one participating member of the board seemed to be learning, as well.

Best I can tell, the process page was prepared by a former board member pushing to reform the process and make it transparent. It was and remains aspirational. But those aspirations aren't shared by remaining participants with sway.

The most straightforward summary of the process I received was that discussion proceeds on the mailing list until it reaches consensus, and then it's entirely within the board's discretion what it does or does not do. It was also written repeatedly that the board may not approve professionally drafted, novel, OSD-conformant licenses, for unspecified policy reasons.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by frockington on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:17PM (#18232318)
Is it your companies official stance that they have the sole right to determine what is OPEN SOURCE code? From an outsider who reads this phrase in countless contexts, this feels like an incredibly naive and non-legally binding opinion
Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by BFatts on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @02:44PM (#18232034)
The OSI defined "Open Source" so they kinda get to put the rules to it. There is an Open Source Definition (OSD) which states what the license to the software can and cannot do. It's primarily about licensing at the OSI, not about open source itself. The definition clarifies what can be considered "open source" so organizations that need structure have something to follow.

As for apps, there's no approval process for an application - only the license applied. And if you use one of the 83 OSI-approved licenses, you can be guaranteed that your software falls under the Open Source Definition, stewarded by the OSI.

So that's how the OSI fits in.

Re:MongoDB switches up its open source license by err4nt on Tuesday October 16, 2018 @03:05PM (#18232198)
It's been a big help to me in both understanding what freedoms I have as a consumer of software, as well as providing me with thoroughly vetted, top-quality licenses to work with when I'm trying to give freedoms to the people who consume my software. OSI is incredibly useful, and have probably saved me needing to consult with a lawyer at least couple of times already. Now spread that benefit across an entire industry to get an idea the amount of value they provide!